i. The Version of Evagrius. Evagrius,
presbyter (Eustathian) and subsequently (388) Bishop at Antioch (in
Italy 364–373), translated the Vita Antonii into Latin. He
prefaced with a short apology (see below, Vit. Ant. §1,
note 1) for the freedom of his rendering, addressed ‘Innocentio
carissimo filio.’ Now this Innocent, the friend of Jerome and
Evagrius, died in the summer of 374, almost exactly a year after the
death of Athanasius (D. C. B. iii. 31, 251). Of this identification
there is no reason to doubt; still less ground is there for the
hesitation (Hist. Lit. I. 283, ‘non una est dubitandi
ratio’) of Cave and others as to the identity of the version,
printed by Montfaucon and transmitted by very numerous mss. (‘quæ ingenti numero vidi,’ Migne
xxv. p. clviii.) with that actually made by Evagrius. Therefore, even
if we make the two very improbable assumptions that the Dedication to
Innocentius falls within a few weeks or days of his death (i.e. during
the journey from Italy to Syria!), and that the Vita was
translated by Evagrius almost immediately upon its composition, the
composition of the Vita falls within a few months of the death
of Athanasius. Its antiquity then ‘is fully conceded’ even
by Mr. Gwatkin (Studies, p. 103, who yet, p. 98, puts it down to
‘the generation after Athanasius!’). The translation of
Evagrius also preserves what looks like the original heading. It should
be added that the Evagrian version (read in the light of its preface),
entirely excludes the hypothesis that the Greek text of the Vita
is interpolated. Evagrius avowedly abridges at times, while in some
cases he embellishes (see §82, note 16).