He asserts that we say that man
has emptied Himself to become man, and that He Who by obedience humbled
Himself to the form of the servant shared the form of men even before
He took that form. No change has been made in the wording; we have
simply transferred the very words from his speech to our own. Now if
there is anything of this sort in our writings, (for I call my
master’s writings ours) let no one blame our orator for
calumny. I ask for all regard for the truth: and we ourselves will give
evidence. But if there is nothing of all this in our writings, while
his language not merely lays blame upon us, but is indignant and
wrathful as if the matter were clearly proved, calling us full of
absurdity, nonsense, confusion, inconsistency, and so on, I am at a
loss to see the right course to take. Just as men who are perplexed at
the groundless rages of madmen can decide upon no plan to follow, so I
myself can find no device to meet this perplexity. Our master says (for
I will again recite his argument verbally), “He is not setting
forth to us the mode of the Divine existence, but the terms which
belong to the Incarnation.” Our accuser starts from this point,
and says that we maintain that man emptied Himself to become man! What
community is there between one statement and the other? If we say that
the Apostle has not set forth to us the mode of the Divine existence,
but points by his phrase to the dispensation of the Passion, we are on
this ground charged with speaking of the “emptying” of man
to become man, and with saying that the “form of the
servant” had pretemporal existence, and that the Man Who was born
of Mary existed before the coming in the flesh! Well, I think it
superfluous to spend time in discussing what is admitted, seeing that
truth itself frees us from the charge. In a case, indeed, where one may
have given the calumniators some handle against oneself, it is proper
to resist accusers: but where there is no danger of being suspected of
some absurd charge, the accusation becomes a proof, not of the false
charge made against him who is calumniated, but of the madness of the
accuser. As, however, in dealing with the charge of being ashamed of
the Cross, we showed by our examination that the charge recoiled upon
the accuser, so we shall show how this charge too returns upon those
who make it, since it is they, and not we, who lay down the doctrine of
the change of the Son from like to like in the dispensation of
the Passion. We will examine briefly, bringing them side by side, the
statements of each party. We say that the Only-begotten God, having by
His own agency brought all things into being, by Himself This
seems to be the force of αὐτῷ; αὐτὸν might
give a simpler construction, but the sense would not be changed.
Oehler, who here restores some words which were omitted in the earlier
editions, makes no mention of any variation of reading. has full power over all things, while the
nature of man is also one of the things that were made by Him: and that
when this had fallen away to evil, and come to be in the destruction of
death, He by His own agency drew it up once more to immortal life, by
means of the Man in whom He tabernacled, taking to Himself humanity in
completeness, and that He mingled His life-giving power with our mortal
and perishable nature, and changed, by the combination with Himself,
our deadness to living grace and power. And this we declare to be the
mystery of the Lord according to the flesh, that He Who is immutable
came to be in that which is mutable, to the end that altering it for
the better, and changing it from the worse, He might abolish the evil
which is mingled with our mutable condition, destroying the evil in
Himself. For “our God is a consuming fire Heb. xii. 29.,” by whom all the material of
wickedness is done away. This is our statement. What does our accuser
say? Not that He Who was immutable and uncreated was mingled with that
which came into being by creation, and which had therefore suffered a
change in the direction of evil; but he does say that He, being Himself
created, came to that which was kindred and homogeneous with Himself,
not coming from a transcendent nature to put on the lowlier nature by
reason of His love to man, but becoming that very thing which He
was.