It may be well to
trace briefly the sense of these technical terms, the history and
significance of which is a forcible reminder of the inability of
Theology to bring the Infinite within the categories of the Finite, to
do more than guard our Faith by pointing out the paths which experience
has shewn to lead to some false limitation of the fulness of the
Revelation of God in Christ.
The distinction (drawn out Prolegg. ch. ii.
§3 (2) b) between the primary and secondary sense of
οὐσία in Greek metaphysics does not easily
fit the doctrine of the Holy Trinity. The
οὐσία common to Father and Son is not the
name of a Species, as ‘Man’ applies to Peter and
Paul. But neither can the idea of πρώτη
οὐσία be reconciled with inherence in three
distinct personal existences. (Cf. supr. p. 409, note 7.)
But here the word
ὑπόστασις comes in to help our imagination. The word (see Socr. H.
E. iii. 7. Westcott, ubi supr. and Newman, Arians,
App. 4), from various literal senses came to be transferred to
the philosophical vocabulary, doing duty as verbal substantive not only
for ὑφεστάναι but for ὑποκεῖσθαι. Like the concrete ὑποκείμενον
it was applied (a) to matter as underlying form, (b)
to substance as underlying attributes. In this latter use it served to
distinguish πρώτη from δευτέρα
οὐσία, expressing
moreover a complete self-contained existence in a way that οὐσία did
not. When therefore the idea of personal individuality has to be
expressed, ὑπόστασις is more suitable than οὐσία. But the
ambiguity of the latter word remains. Those who preferred to speak
of μία
ὑπόστασις thought of the Divine Essence rather as πρώτη
οὐσία, and of One
Personal God, with whom Father, Son, and Spirit were each absolutely
and fully identified (περιχώρησις), while with those who preferred πρεῖς
ὑποστάσεις
the idea of the Divine οὐσία approximated to δευτέρα
οὐσία, and guarded
against Tritheism solely by holding fast to the Monarchia of the
Father. The corrective to each position lay in the recognition of the
other, i.e. of its own incompleteness. (See further Prolegg. ubi
supr. and Zahn, Marcell. p. 87, sq.)