9. O. I do not deny that it is the practice of the
Churches in the case of those who living far from the greater towns
have been baptized by presbyters and deacons, for the bishop to visit
them, and by the laying on of hands to invoke the Holy Ghost upon them.
But how shall I describe your habit of applying the laws of the Church
to heretics, and of exposing the virgin entrusted to you in the
brothels of harlots? If a bishop lays his hands on men he lays them on
those who have been baptized in the right faith, and who have believed
that the Father, Son, and Holy Ghost, are three persons, but one
essence. But an Arian has no faith but this (close your ears, my
hearers, that you may not be defiled by words so grossly impious), that
the Father alone is very God, and that Jesus Christ our Saviour is a The Arians said He
was the creature (made out of nothing) through whom the Father gave
being to all other creatures.creature, and The Macedonians,
who became nearly co-extensive with the Semi-Arians about 360, held
that the Spirit not being ‘very’ God must be a creature and
therefore a Servant of God.the Holy Ghost the Servant of both. How
can he then receive the Holy Ghost from the Church, who has not yet
obtained remission of sins? For the Holy Ghost must have a clean abode:
nor will He become a dweller in that temple which has not for its chief
priest the true faith. But if you now ask how it is that a person
baptized in the Church does not receive the Holy Ghost, Whom we declare
to be given in true baptism, except by the hands of the bishop, let me
tell you that our authority for the rule is the fact that after our
Lord’s ascension the Holy Ghost descended upon the Apostles. And
in many places we find it the practice, more by way of honouring the
Sacerdotium—often used by Jerome in a special sense for the
Episcopate. He says of Pammachius and of himself (Letter xlv., 3) that
many people thought them digni sacerdotio, meaning the Bishopric of
Rome.episcopate than from any compulsory law.
Otherwise, if the Holy Ghost descends only at the bishop’s
prayer, they are greatly to be pitied who in isolated houses, or in
forts, or retired places, after being baptized by the presbyters and
deacons have fallen asleep before the bishop’s visitation. The
well-being of a Church depends upon the dignity of its chief-priest,
and unless some extraordinary and unique functions be assigned to him,
we shall have as many schisms in the Churches as there are priests.
Hence it is that without ordination and the bishop’s license
neither presbyter nor deacon has the power to baptize. And yet, if
necessity so be, we know that even laymen may, and frequently do,
baptize. For as a man receives, so too he can give; for it will hardly
be said that we must believe that
the eunuch whom Philip Acts viii. 26 sq. baptized
lacked the Holy Spirit. The Scripture thus speaks concerning him,
“And they both went down into the water; and Philip baptized
him.” And on leaving the water, “The Holy Spirit fell upon
the eunuch.” You may perhaps think that we ought to set against
this the passage in which we read, “Now when the apostles which
were at Jerusalem heard that Samaria had received the word of God, they
sent unto them Peter and John: who, when they were come down, prayed
for them that they might receive the Holy Ghost: for as yet he was
fallen upon none of them.” But why this was, the context tells
us,—“Only they had been baptized into the name of the Lord
Jesus. Then laid they their hands on them, and they received the Holy
Ghost.” And if you here say that you do the same, because the
heretics have not baptized into the Holy Spirit, I must remind you that
Philip was not separated from the Apostles, but belonged to the same
Church and preached the same Lord Jesus Christ: that he was without
question a deacon of those who afterwards laid their hands on his
converts. But when you say that the Arians have not a Church, but a
synagogue, and that their clergy do not worship God but creatures and
idols, how can you maintain that you ought to act upon the same
principle in cases so totally different?