5. But they say
that those should not be restored to communion who have fallen into
denial
Prævaricatio. of the
faith. If they made the crime of sacrilege the only exception to
receiving forgiveness, they would be acting harshly indeed, and, as it
would seem, would be in opposition to the divine utterances only, while
consistent with their own assertions. For when the Lord forgave
all sins, He made an exception of none. But since, as it were
after the fashion of the Stoics, they think that all sins are equal in
gravity, and assert that he who has stolen a common fowl, as they say,
no less than he who has smothered his father, should be for ever
excluded from the divine mysteries, how can they select those guilty of
one special offence, since even they themselves cannot deny that it is
most unjust that the penalty of one should extend to many? i.e. the
penalty of the one sin of denying the faith should be extended to all
sins.