The Ecumenical Councils claimed for themselves an
immunity from error in their doctrinal and moral teaching, resting such
claim upon the promise of the presence and guidance of the Holy
Ghost. The Council looked upon itself, not as revealing any new
truth, but as setting forth the faith once for all delivered to the
Saints, its decisions therefore were in themselves ecumenical, as being
an expression of the mind of the whole body of the faithful both
clerical and lay, the sensus communis of the Church. And
by the then teaching of the Church that ecumenical consensus was
considered free from the suspicion of error, guarded, (as was
believed,) by the Lord’s promise that the gates of hell should
not prevail against his Church. This then is what Catholics mean
when they affirm the infallibility of Ecumenical Councils.
Whether this opinion is true or false is a question outside the scope
of the present discussion. It was necessary, however, to state
that these Councils looked upon themselves as divinely protected in
their decisions from error in faith and morals, lest the reader should
otherwise be at a loss to understand the anathematisms which follow the
decrees, and which indeed would be singularly out of place, if the
decrees which they thus emphatically affirm were supposed to rest only
upon human wisdom and speculation, instead of upon divine
authority.