According to the Liberian catalogue, Marcellinus became bishop on
the 30th of June, 296, and held office for eight years three months and
twenty-five days, i.e. until the 25th of October, 304, and these dates
Lipsius accepts as correct, although there is considerable uncertainty
as to the exact date of his death. Jerome’s version of the
Chron. puts his accession in the twelfth year of Diocletian,
which is not far out of the way, but does not give the duration of his
episcopate, nor does Eusebius in his History. The Armenian
Chron. does not mention Marcellinus at all. Tradition, although
denied by many of the Fathers, says that he proved wanting in the
Diocletian persecution, and this seems to have been a fact. It is also
said that he afterward repented and suffered martyrdom, but that is
only an invention. The expression of Eusebius in this connection is
ambiguous; he simply says he was “overtaken by the
persecution,” which might mean martyrdom, or might mean simply
arrest. The eleven bishops that preceded him from Pontianus to Caius
were buried in the Catacombs of St. Calixtus, but he was buried in
those of Priscilla.