Vincentius’s copy
of the acts of the Council appears to have contained extracts from no
more than ten Fathers. But the Fathers from whose writings extracts
were read were twelve in number; the two omitted by Vincentius being
Atticus, bishop of Constantinople, and Amphilochius, bishop of Iconium.
In Labbe’s Concilia, where the whole are given, it is
remarked that in one manuscript the two last mentioned occupy a
different place from the others.
Dean Milman (Latin
Christianity, vol. 1, p. 164) speaks of the passages read,
“as of very doubtful bearing on the question raised by
Nestorius.” It is true only two, those from Athanasius and
Gregory Nazianzen, contain the crucial term
“Theotocos” but all express the truth which
“Theotocos” symbolises. That the word was not of
recent introduction, Bishop Pearson (Creed, Art. 3) shows by
quotations from other writers besides those produced at the Council,
going back as far as to Origen.
The Fathers cited may certainly be said
to fulfil to some extent Vincentius’s requirement of
universality. They represent the teaching of Alexandria, Rome,
Carthage, Milan, Constantinople, and Asia Minor; but his appeal would
have been more to his purpose if antiquity had been more expressly
represented. With the exception of Cyprian, all the passages cited were
from writers of comparatively recent date at the time, though, as
Vincentius truly remarks, others might have been produced.
Petavius (De Incarn. l. xiv. c.
15), in defending the cultus of the blessed Virgin and of the
saints generally, lays much stress on this omission of citations from
earlier Fathers at the Council, as he does also on similar omissions in
the case of the fourth, fifth, and sixth Councils, with what object is
sufficiently obvious. Bishop Bull points out Petavius’s
disposition to disparage or misrepresent the teaching of the earlier
Fathers, in another and still more important instance. (Defens. Fid.
Nic.) Introd. § 8.