For to me, as you know, when I was resident at the footsteps of my lords in the royal city, many used to come of those who
were accused with respect to the aforesaid points. But I declare,
my conscience bearing me witness, that I never found in them any error,
any pravity, or anything of what was said against them. Whence
also I took care, despising report, to receive them familiarly, and
rather to defend them from their accusers. For it used to be said
against them that under pretext of religion they dissolved marriages;
and that they said that baptism did not entirely take away sins; and
that, if any one did penance for three years for his iniquities, he
might afterwards live perversely; and that, if they said under
compulsion that they anathematized anything for which they were blamed,
they were by no means holden by the bond of anathema. Now if
there are any who undoubtedly hold and maintain such views, there is no
doubt that they are not Christians. And such both I, and all
catholic bishops, and the universal Church, anathematize, because they
think what is contrary to the truth, and speak what is contrary.
For, if they say that marriages should be dissolved for the sake of
religion Religionis, in
the sense of monastic life., be it known that,
though human law has conceded this, yet divine law has forbidden
it. For the Truth in person says, What God hath joined
together let not man put asunder (Matth. xix. 6). He says also, It is not
lawful for a man to put away his wife saving for the cause of
fornication (Ibid. 9). Who then may contradict
this heavenly legislator? We know how it is written, Two shall
be one flesh (Matth. xix. 5; 1 Cor. vi. 16; Gen. ii. 24). If, then, a man and wife are one flesh, and a man puts away his wife for the sake
of religion, or a woman her husband while he remains in this world,
even though perchance he turns aside to unlawful deeds, what is this
conversion Conversio, in
the usual sense of embracing monastic life., in which one and
the same flesh on the one part passes to continence and on the other
part remains in pollution? If, however, it should suit both to
lead a continent life, who may dare to accuse them, since it is certain
that Almighty God, who has granted what is less, has not forbidden what
is greater? And indeed we know of many holy persons who have both
previously led continent lives with their consorts, and have afterwards
passed over to the rules of holy Church. For in two ways holy men
are accustomed to abstain even from lawful things. Sometimes that
they may increase their merits before Almighty God; but sometimes that
they may wipe away the sins of their former life. For when the
three children who were brought under obedience to the Babylonian King,
asked for pulse for food, being unwilling to make use of the
king’s meat, it
was not because it would have been sin in them to eat what God had
created. They were unwilling, then, to take what it was lawful
for them to take, that their virtue might increase through
continence. But David, who had taken to himself another
man’s wife, and had been sorely scourged for his fault, desired
long afterwards to drink water from the cistern of Bethlehem; which
when his bravest soldiers had brought to him, he refused to drink it,
and poured it out as a libation to the Lord. For it was lawful
for him to drink it, had he been so minded; but, because he remembered
having done what was unlawful, he laudably abstained even from what was
lawful. And he, who to his guilt previously feared not that the
blood of dying soldiers should be shed, afterwards considered that,
were he to drink the water, he would have shed the blood of living
soldiers, saying, Shall I drink the blood of these men who have put
their lives in jeopardy (1 Chron. xi. 19)? Accordingly, when good
husbands and wives desire either to increase merit or to do away with
the faults of previous life, it is lawful for them to bind themselves
to continence and to aspire to a better life. But, if the wife
does not follow after the continence which the husband aspires to, or
the husband refuses that which the wife aspires to, it is not lawful
for wedlock to be cut asunder, seeing that it is written, The wife
hath not power of her own body, but the husband; and the husband hath
not power of his own body, but the wife (1 Cor. vii. 4).