1850-1] CATHERINE'S IDEAL GARDEN 57
too, judging by his Tracts, and by " The Religions of the
World," a curious vagueness about Mr. Maurice's style.
He seems to take such pains to guard what he says, and to
say it in the simplest language, that I am always expecting
a very clear statement, and am surprized, when I come to
the end of the sentence, to find it not so clear as I thought
it was. This is never the case when it is a moral question
that has to be decided, but, as it appears to me, constantly
the case where intellectual opinions are concerned. But he
must be an extraordinary man to exert such influence over
the young men who come in his way, as he appears to
have done.
The same to the same
MALVERN, June jth, 1850.
I have now read a good deal of " Phases of Faith." l It
is a very strange book, so very open ; here and there so
much feeling expressed, and yet a great deal of it is so
hard ; which, however, is but proper, where mere reasoning
is concerned ; onlyhe never speaks of Christ otherwise than
hardly even depreciatingly ; there is something very pain-
ful to me in the tone of all those passages, they are so
different from his manner when he speaks of St. Paul ; that
is invariably reverential, even when he is controverting his
infallibility.
CATHERINE to ELIZA PATERSON
ADELAIDE HOUSE, GREAT MALVERN,
July 14, 1850.
The roses of Malvern are most lovely, and our little
garden is full of them. It is just such a garden as Mrs.
Gaskell would like, with scarcely any grass in it, but laid
out in terraces with narrow gravel walks, and beds of flowers
beside them (only some of these terraces have potatoes !).
Itmakes me wish I had a house and garden here, the garden
should be laid out in terraces with marble steps leading
down from one to the other, and basins of water with
fountains, and at the bottom a great sweep of lawn, to give
a proper greenness to the whole, and very pretty it would
1
By F. W. Newman.