Chapter 17.—18. Then he further adds: "Both are without the life of baptism, both he
who never had it at all, and he who had it but has lost it." He therefore never had it, whom
Felicianus, the follower of Maximianus or Prætextatus, baptized outside; and these men
themselves have lost what once they had when, therefore, these were received with their
followers, who gave to those whom they baptized what previously they did not have? and
who restored to themselves what they had lost? But they took away with them the form of
baptism, but lost the veritable excellence of baptism by their wicked schism. Why do you
repudiate the form itself, which is holy at all times and all places, in the Catholics whom
you have not heard, whilst you are willing to acknowledge it in the followers of Maximianus
whom you have punished?
19. But whatever he seemed to himself to say by way of accusation about the traitor
Judas, I see not how it can concern us, who are not proved by them to have betrayed our
trust; nor, indeed, if such treason were proved on the part of any who before our time have
died in our communion, would that treason in any way defile us by whom it was disavowed,
and to whom it was displeasing. For if they themselves are not defiled by offenses condemned
by themselves, and afterwards condoned, how much less can we be defiled by what we have
disavowed so soon as we have heard of them! However weighty, therefore, his invective
against traditors, let him be assured that they are condemned by me in precisely the same
terms. But yet I make a distinction; for he accuses one on my side who has long been dead
without having been condemned in any investigation made by me. I point to a man adhering
closely to his side, who had been condemned by him, or at least had been separated by a
sacrilegious schism, and whom he received again with undiminished honor.
Chapter 17
998
Chapter 17