Chapter XXV
.—
The Apocalypse of John.
2340
1.
Afterward
he speaks in this manner of the Apocalypse of
John.
“Some before us have set
aside and rejected the book altogether, criticising it chapter by
chapter, and pronouncing it without sense or argument, and maintaining
that the title is fraudulent.
2. For they say that it is not
the work of John, nor is it a revelation, because it is covered thickly
and densely by a vail of obscurity. And they affirm that none of the
apostles, and none of the saints, nor any one in the Church is its
author, but that Cerinthus, who founded the sect which was called after
him the Cerinthian, desiring reputable authority for his fiction,
prefixed the name.
3. For the doctrine which he
taught was this: that the kingdom of Christ will be an earthly one. And
as he was himself devoted to the pleasures of the body and altogether
sensual in his nature, he dreamed that that kingdom would consist in
those things which he desired, namely, in the delights of the belly and
of sexual passion; that is to say, in eating and drinking and marrying,
and in festivals and sacrifices and the slaying of victims, under the
guise of which he thought he could indulge his appetites with a better
grace.
2341
4. “But I could not
venture to reject the book, as many brethren hold it in high esteem.
But I suppose that it is beyond my comprehension, and that there is a
certain concealed and more wonderful meaning in every part. For if I do
not understand I suspect that a deeper sense lies beneath the
words.
5. I do not measure and judge
them by my own reason, but leaving the more to faith I regard them as
too high for me to grasp. And I do not reject what I cannot comprehend,
but rather wonder because I do not understand it.”
6. After this he examines the
entire Book of Revelation, and having proved that it is impossible to
understand it according to the literal sense, proceeds as
follows:
“Having finished all the
prophecy, so to speak, the prophet pronounces those blessed who shall
observe it, and also himself. For he says, ‘Blessed is he that
keepeth the words of the prophecy of this book, and I, John, who saw
and heard these things.’
2342
7. Therefore that he was called
John, and that this book is the work of one John, I do not deny. And I
agree also that it is the work of a holy and inspired man. But I cannot
readily admit that he was the apostle, the son of Zebedee, the brother
of James, by whom the Gospel of John and the Catholic Epistle
2343
were written.
8. For I judge from the
character of both, and the forms of expression, and the entire
execution of the book,
2344
that it is not
his. For
the evangelist nowhere gives his name, or proclaims himself,
either in the Gospel or Epistle.”
9. Farther on he
adds:
“But John never speaks as
if referring to himself, or as if referring to another person.
2345
But the author of the Apocalypse
introduces himself at the very beginning: ‘The Revelation of
Jesus Christ, which he gave him to show unto his servants quickly; and
he sent and signified it by his angel unto his servant John, who bare
witness of the word of God and of his testimony, even of all things
that he saw.’
2346
10. Then he writes also an
epistle: ‘John to the seven churches which are in Asia, grace be
with you, and peace.’
2347
But the
evangelist did not prefix his name even to the Catholic Epistle; but
without introduction he begins with the mystery of the divine
revelation itself: ‘That which was from the beginning, which we
have heard, which we have seen with our eyes.’
2348
For because of such a revelation the
Lord also blessed Peter, saying, ‘Blessed art thou, Simon
Bar-Jonah, for flesh and blood hath not revealed it unto thee, but my
heavenly Father.’
2349
11. But neither in the reputed
second or third epistle of John, though they are very short, does the
name John appear; but there is written the anonymous phrase, ‘the
elder.’
2350
But this author
did not consider it sufficient to give his name once and to proceed
with his work; but he takes it up again: ‘I, John, who also am
your brother and companion in tribulation, and in the kingdom and in
the patience of Jesus Christ, was in the isle that is called Patmos for
the Word of God and the testimony of Jesus.’
2351
And toward the close he speaks thus:
‘Blessed is he that keepeth the words of the prophecy of this
book, and I, John, who saw and heard these things.’
2352
12. “But that he who wrote
these things was called John must be believed, as he says it; but who
he was does not appear. For he did not say, as often in the Gospel,
that he was the beloved disciple of the Lord,
2353
or the one who lay on his breast,
2354
or the brother of James, or the
eyewitness and hearer of the Lord.
13. For he would have spoken of
these things if he had wished to show himself plainly. But he says none
of them; but speaks of himself as our brother and companion, and a
witness of Jesus, and blessed because he had seen and heard the
revelations.
14. But I am of the opinion that
there were many with the same name as the apostle John, who, on account
of their love for him, and because they admired and emulated him, and
desired to be loved by the Lord as he was, took to themselves the same
surname, as many of the children of the faithful are called Paul or
Peter.
15. For example, there is also
another John, surnamed Mark, mentioned in the Acts of the Apostles,
2355
whom Barnabas and Paul took with them; of
whom also it is said, ‘And they had also John as their
attendant.’
2356
But that it is
he who wrote this, I would not say. For it not written that he went
with them into Asia, but, ‘Now when Paul and his company set sail
from Paphos, they came to Perga in Pamphylia and John departing from
them returned to Jerusalem.’
2357
16. But I think that he was some
other one of those in Asia; as they say that there are two monuments in
Ephesus, each bearing the name of John.
2358
17. “And from the ideas,
and from the words and their arrangement, it may be reasonably
conjectured that this one is different from that one.
2359
18. For the Gospel and Epistle
agree with each other and begin in the same manner. The one says,
‘In the beginning was the Word’;
2360
the other, ‘That which was from the beginning.’
2361
The one: ‘And the Word was made
flesh and dwelt among us, and we beheld his glory, the glory as of the
only begotten of the Father’;
2362
the other
says the same things slightly altered: ‘Which we have heard,
which we have seen with our eyes; which we have looked upon and our
hands have handled of the Word of life,—and the life was
manifested.’
2363
19. For he introduces these
things at the beginning, maintaining them, as is evident from what
follows, in opposition to those who said that the Lord had not come in
the flesh. Wherefore also he carefully adds, ‘And we have seen
and bear witness, and declare unto you the eternal life which was with
the Father and was manifested unto us. That which we have seen and
heard declare we unto you also.’
2364
20. He holds to this and does
not digress from his subject, but discusses every
thing under the same heads and
names some of which we will briefly mention.
21. Any one who examines
carefully will find the phrases, ‘the life,’ ‘the
light,’ ‘turning from darkness,’ frequently occurring
in both; also continually, ‘truth,’ ‘grace,’
‘joy,’ ‘the flesh and blood of the Lord,’
‘the judgment,’ ‘the forgiveness of sins,’
‘the love of God toward us,’ the ‘commandment that we
love one another,’ that we should ‘keep all the
commandments’; the ‘conviction of the world, of the Devil,
of Anti-Christ,’ the ‘promise of the Holy Spirit,’
the ‘adoption of God,’ the ‘faith continually
required of us,’ ‘the Father and the Son,’ occur
everywhere. In fact, it is plainly to be seen that one and the same
character marks the Gospel and the Epistle throughout.
22. But the Apocalypse is
different from these writings and foreign to them; not touching, nor in
the least bordering upon them; almost, so to speak, without even a
syllable in common with them.
23. Nay more, the
Epistle—for I pass by the Gospel—does not mention nor does
it contain any intimation of the Apocalypse, nor does the Apocalypse of
the Epistle. But Paul, in his epistles, gives some indication of his
revelations,
2365
though he has not written them out
by themselves.
24. “Moreover, it can also
be shown that the diction of the Gospel and Epistle differs from that
of the Apocalypse.
25. For they were written not
only without error as regards the Greek language, but also with
elegance in their expression, in their reasonings, and in their entire
structure. They are far indeed from betraying any barbarism or
solecism, or any vulgarism whatever. For the writer had, as it seems,
both the requisites of discourse,—that is, the gift of knowledge
and the gift of expression,—as the Lord had bestowed them both
upon him.
26. I do not deny that the other
writer saw a revelation and received knowledge and prophecy. I
perceive, however, that his dialect and language are not accurate
Greek, but that he uses barbarous idioms, and, in some places,
solecisms.
27. It is unnecessary to point
these out here, for I would not have any one think that I have said
these things in a spirit of ridicule, for I have said what I have only
with the purpose of showing clearly the difference between the
writings.”
2340
Upon the Apocalypse in the early Church, and especially upon
Dionysius’ treatment of it, see above, Bk. III. chap. 24, note
20.
2341
A
portion of this extract (§§2 and 3) has been already quoted
by Eusebius in Bk. III. chap. 28.
2342
Rev. xxii. 7,
8
.
Dionysius punctuates this passage peculiarly, and thus interprets it
quite differently from all our versions of the Book of Revelation. The
Greek text as given by him agrees with our received text of the
Apocalypse; but the words
κἀγὼ
᾽Ιω€ννης ὁ
ἀκούων καὶ
βλέπων
ταῦτα
, which
Dionysius connects with the preceding, should form an independent
sentence: “And I, John, am he that heard and saw these
things.”
2343
On the Gospel and Epistle, see Bk. III. chap. 24, notes 1 and
18.
2344
τῆς τοῦ
βιβλίου
διεξαγωγῆς
λεγομένης
. Valesius considers
διεξαγωγή
equivalent to
dispositionem
or
οἰκονομίαν
, “for
διεξαγωγεῖν
is the same as
διοικεῖν
, as Suidas says.” He translates
ex libelli totius
ductu ac dispositione,
remarking that the words may be interpreted
also as
formam et rationem scribendi, seu characterem.
The
phrase evidently means the “general disposition” or
“form” of the work. Closs translates “aus ihrer
ganzen Ausführung”; Salmond, “the whole disposition
and execution of the book”; Crusè, “the execution of
the whole book.”
2345
i.e. never speaks of himself in the first person, as “I,
John”; nor in the third person, as e.g. “his servant,
John.”
2346
Rev. i. 1, 2
.
2347
Rev. i. 4
.
2348
1 John i. 1
.
2349
Matt. xvi. 17
.
2350
See
2 John, ver. 1, and 3 John,
ver. 1
.
2351
Rev. i. 9
.
2352
Rev. xxii. 7,
8
.
See above, note 3.
2353
See
John xiii. 23, xix. 26, xx. 2, xxi. 7, 20
.
2354
See
John xiii. 23, 25
. These words,
οὐδὲ
τὸν
ἀναπεσόντα
ἐπὶ τὸ
στῆθος
αὐτοῦ
, are wanting
in Heinichen’s edition; but as they are found in all the other
editions and versions and Heinichen gives no reason for their omission,
it is clear that they have been omitted inadvertently.
2355
In
Acts xii. 12, 25; xiii. 5, 13; xv. 37
. On Mark and the second
Gospel, see above, Bk. II. chap. 15, note 4.
2356
Acts xiii. 5
.
2357
Acts xiii. 13
.
2358
See above, Bk. III. chap. 39, note 13; and on the “presbyter
John,” mentioned by Papias, see also note 4 on the same chapter,
and on his relation to the Apocalypse, the same chapter, note
14.
2359
i.e. the writer of the Apocalypse is different from the writer of
the Gospel and Epistles.
2360
John i. 1
.
2361
1 John i. 1
.
2362
John i. 14
.
2363
1 John i. 1,
2
.
2364
1 John i. 2,
3
.
2365
See
2 Cor. xii. 1
sq.,
Gal. ii. 2
.