I am not aware whether any writer has preceded or
followed this great authority in this view Waterland expresses the view here taken, and not Bishop
Bull’s; vol. i. p. 114. Bull’s language, on the other hand,
is very strong: ‘Sæpe olim, ut verum ingenue fateai, animum
meum subiit admiratio, quid effato isto, ‘Filius priusquam
nasceretur, non erat,’ sibi voluerint Ariani. De
nativitate Christi ex beatissima Virgine dictum non esse exponendum
constat.…Itaque de nativitate Filii loquuntur, quæ hujus
universi creationem antecessit. Quis vero, inquam, sensus
dicti hujus “Filius non erat, sive non existebat, priusquam
nasceretur ex Patre ante conditum mundum?” Ego sane nullus
dubito, quin hoc pronunciatum Arianorum oppositum fuerit Catholicorum
istorum sententiæ, qui docerent, Filium quidem paulo ante conditum
mundum inexplicabili quodam modo ex Patre progressum fuisse ad
constituendum universa, &c. D. F. N. iii. 9.
§2..
The more obvious mode of understanding the Arian formula is this, that
it is an argument ex absurdo, drawn from the force of the word
Son, in behalf of the Arian doctrine; it being, as they would say, a
truism, that, ‘whereas He was begotten, He was not before
He was begotten,’ and the denial of it a contradiction in terms.
This certainly does seem to myself the true force of the formula; so
much so, that if Bishop Bull’s explanation be admissible, it
must, in order to its being so, first be shewn to be reducible to this
sense, and to be included under it.