Introduction, by the American Editor.
————————————
The
Second Class of
Tertullian’s works, according to the logical method I have
endeavoured to carry out, is that which includes his treatises against
the heresies of his times. In these, the genius of our author is
brilliantly illustrated, while, in melancholy fact, he is demonstrating
the folly of his own final lapse and the wickedness of that schism and
heresy into which he fell away from Truth. Were it not that history
abounds in like examples of the frailty of the human intellect and of
the insufficiency of “man that walketh to direct his
steps,” we should be forced to a theory of mental decay to
account for inconsistencies so gross and for delusions so besotted.
“Genius to madness is
indeed
allied,” and who knows
but something like that imbecility which closed the career of
Swift
1846
may have been the fate of this splendid wit
and versatile man of parts? Charity, admiration and love force this
inquiry upon my own mind continually, as I explore his fascinating
pages. And the order in which the student will find them in this
series, will lead, I think, to similar reflections on the part of many
readers. We observe a natural bent and turn of mind, even in his
Catholic writings, which indicate his perils. These are more and more
apparent in his recent works, as his enthusiasm heats itself into a
frenzy which at last becomes a rage. He breaks down by degrees, as in
orthodoxy so also in force and in character. It is almost like the
collapse of Solomon or of Bacon. And though our own times have produced
no example of stars of equal magnitude, to become falling-stars, we
have seen illustrations the most humiliating, of those calm words of
Bishop Kaye: “Human nature often presents the curious phenomenon
of an union of the most opposite qualities in the same mind; of vigour,
acuteness and discrimination on some subjects, with imbecility, dulness
and bigotry on others.” Milton, himself another example of his
own threnode, breaks forth in this splendid utterance of lyrical
confession:
“God of our fathers what is man?
Nor do I name of men the common rout,
That, wandering loose about,
Grow up and perish as the summer fly,
Heads without name, no more remembered,
But such as thou hast solemnly elected,
With gifts and graces eminently adorned,
To some great work, thy glory
And people’s safety,
which in part they
effect
.”
And here, I must venture a remark on the ambiguity
of the expressions concerning our author’s Montanism. In the
treatise against Marcion, written late in his career, Tertullian
identifies himself with the Church and strenuously defends its faith
and its apostolic order. In only rare instances does his weakness
for the “new prophecy” crop out, and then, it is only as
one identifies himself with a school within the church. Precisely so
Fenelon maintained his milder Montanism, without a thought of deserting
the Latin Church. Afterwards Fenelon drew back, but at last poor
Tertullian fell away. So with the Jansenists. They credited the
miracles
and the
convulsions
(or ecstasies) of their
school,
1847
and condemned
those
who rejected
them, as Tertullian condemns the
Psychics
. The great expounder
of the Nicene Faith (Bp. Bull) does indeed speak very decidedly of
Tertullian as a
lapser
, even when he wrote his first book
against Marcion. His semi-schismatic position must be allowed. But, was
it a
formal
lapse at that time? The English non-jurors were long
in communion with the Church, even while they denounced their brethren
and the “Erastianizing” clergy, much as Tertullian does the
Psychics
. St. Augustine speaks of
Tertullianists
1848
with great moderation, and notes the final
downfall of our author as something distinct from Tertullianism. When
we reflect, therefore, that only four of all his varied writings (now
extant) are proofs of an accomplished lapse, ought we not carefully to
maintain the distinction between the Montanistic Tertullian and
Tertullian the Montanist? Bishop Bull, it seems to me would not object
to this way of putting it, when we consider his own discrimination in
the following weighty words. He says:
“A clear distinction must be made between
those works which Tertullian, when already a Montanist, wrote
specifically in defence of Montanism
against the church
, and
those which he composed, as a Montanist indeed, yet
not in defence
of Montanism against the church
, but rather,
in defence of the
common doctrines of the church
—and of Montanus, in opposition
to other heretics.”
Now in arranging the works of this second class,
the Prescription
comes logically first, because, written in
Orthodoxy, it forcibly upholds the Scriptural Rule of Faith, the
Catholic touchstone of all professed verity. It is also a necessary
Introduction to the great work against Marcion which I have placed next
in order; giving it the precedence to which it is entitled in part on
chronological ground, in part because of the general purity of its
material with the exhibition it presents of the author’s mental
processes and of his very gradual decline from Truth.
Very fortunate were the Edinburgh Editors in
securing for this work and some others, the valuable labours of Dr.
Holmes, of whom I have elsewhere given some biographical particulars.
The merit and fulness of his annotations are so marked, that I have
been spared a great deal of work, such as I was forced to bestow on the
former volumes of this American Edition. But on the other hand these
pages have given me much patient study and toil as an editor, because
of the “shreds and patches” in which Tertullian comes to
us, in the Edinburgh Series; and because of some typographical
peculiarities, exceptional in that Series itself, and presenting
complications, when transferred to a new form of mechanical
arrangement. For example, apart from some valuable material which
belongs to the General Preface, and which I have transferred
accordingly, the following dislocations confronted me to begin with:
The
Marcion
is presented to us in Volume VII. apart from the
other writings of Tertullian. At the close of Vol. XI. we reach the
Ad Nationes
, of which Dr. Holmes is the translator, another hand
(Mr. Thelwall’s) having been employed on former pages of that
volume. It is not till we reach Volume XV. that Tertullian again
appears, but this volume is wholly the work of Dr. Holmes.
Finally, in Volume XVIII., we meet Tertullian again, (Mr. Thelwall the
able translator), but, here is placed the “Introduction” to
all the works of Tertullian, which, of course, I have, transferred to
its proper place. I make these explanations by no means censoriously,
but to point out at once the nature of my own task, and the advantage
that accrues to the reader, by the order in which the works of the
great Tertullian appear in this edition, enabling him to compare
different or parallel passages, all methodically arranged in
consecutive pages, without a minute’s search, or
delay.
Now, as to typographical difficulties to which I
have referred, Dr. Holmes marks all his multiplied and useful notes
with
brackets
, which are almost always superfluous, and which
in
this American
Edition are used to designate my own contributions, when printed with
the text, or apart from Preface and Elucidations. These, therefore, I
have removed necessarily and with no appreciable loss to the work, but
great gain to the beauty of the page. But, again, Dr. Holmes’
translations are all so heavily bracketed as to become an eyesore, and
the disfigured pages have been often complained of as afflictive to the
reader. Many words strictly implied by the original Latin, and which
should therefore be unmarked, are yet put between brackets. Even minute
words (
and
, or
to wit
, or
again
,) when, in the
nature of the case the English idiom requires them, are thus marked. I
have not retained these blemishes; but when an inconsiderable word or a
repetition does add to the sense, or qualify it, I have italicized such
words, throwing more important interpolations into parenthetical marks,
which are less painful to the sight than brackets. I have found them
quite as serviceable to denote the auxiliary word or phrase; and where
the author himself uses a parenthesis, I have observed very few
instances in which a sensible reader would confound it with the
translator’s efforts to eke out the sense. Sometimes, an awkward
interpolation has been thrown into a footnote. Occasionally the
crabbed sentences of the great Carthaginian are so obscure that Dr.
Holmes has been unable to make them lucid, although, with the original
in hand, he probably felt a force in his own rendering which the mere
English reader must fail to perceive. In a few such instances, noting
the fact in the margin, I have tried to bring out the sense, by slight
modifications of punctuation and arrangement. Occasionally too I have
dropped a superfluous interpolation (such as
e.g.
,
to
conclude
, or let me say again,) when I have found that it only
served to clog and overcharge a sentence. Last of all, Dr.
Holmes’
headings
have sometimes been condensed, to avoid
phrases and sentences immediately recurring in the chapter.
1849
These purely mechanical parts require a
terse form of statement, like those in the English Bible, and I have
frequently reduced them on that model, dropping redundant adverbs and
adjectives to bring out the catchwords.
1846
“From
Marlboro’s eyes the tears of dotage flow,
And Swift expires a driveller and a
show.”
1847
See the story of the
Abbé Paris, Guettée,
Histoire de
L’Eglise de France
, Tom. xii. p. 12. Also,
Parton,
Voltaire
, Vol. I. pp. 236, 261, etc.
1848
See opp. Tom. viii. p.
46, Ed. Migne.
1849
Take e.g. the heading
to chapter xxiv. of the
De Præscriptione
. It reads
thus: “
St. Peter’s further vindication. St. Paul was not
at all superior to St. Peter in teaching. Nothing was imparted to the
former, in the “third heaven,” to enable him to add to the
faith—however foolishly the heretics may boast of him as if they
had, forsooth, been favoured with some of the secrets so imparted to
him in paradise.
” If the reader will turn to the chapter
referred to, he will observe an instance of condensation by which
nothing is forfeited that is requisite to a
heading
, though
redundancies are dropped.