\par\par\pard (\cf13\b And if he shall neglect to hear them, tell (\i it) unto the church: but if he neglect to hear the church, let him be unto thee as a heathen man and a publican.)
\par\par (\cf13\i [Tell it unto the church.]) That which was incumbent upon him against whom the sin was committed was this, that he should deliver his soul by reproving his brother, and by not suffering sin in him. This was the reason that he had need of witnesses, for what else could they testify? They could not testify that the brother had sinned against him that reproved him; for this, perhaps, they were altogether ignorant of: but they might testify this, that he against whom the sin was committed used due reproof, and omitted nothing which was commanded by the law in that case, whereby he might admonish his brother, and, if possible, bring him back into the right way. The witnesses also added their friendly admonition: whom if the offender hearkened not unto, "let it be told the church."
\par\par We do not here enter upon that long dispute concerning the sense of the word (\i church) in this place. However you take it, certainly the business here is not so much concerning the censure of the person sinning, as concerning the vindication of the person reproving; that it might be known to all that he discharged his duty, and freed his soul.
\par\par It was very customary among the Jews to note those that were obstinate in this or that crime after public admonition given them in the synagogue, and to set a mark of infamy upon them.
\par\par (\i All these have need of public admonition in the consistory). The business there is about some shepherds, collectors, and publicans; and it is declared how incapable they are of giving evidence in any judiciary matter; but not before public admonition is gone out against them in the consistory.
\par\par "If any deny to feed his children, they reprove him, they shame him, they urge him: if he still refuse, they make proclamation against him in the synagogue, saying, 'N. is a cruel man, and will not nourish his children: more cruel than the unclean birds themselves, for they feed their young ones,' " etc.
\par\par "A provoking wife who saith, 'I will create vexation to my husband, because he hath done thus or thus to me, or because he hath miscalled me, or because he hath chid me,' etc. The consistory by messengers send these words to her, 'Be it known unto you, if you persist in your perverseness, although your dowry be a hundred pounds, you have lost it all.' (\i And moreover they set forth a public proclamation against her in the synagogues, and in the divinity schools) every day for four sabbaths."
\par\par (\cf13\i [Let him be to thee as a heathen and a publican.]) He saith, (\i Let him be to 'thee'); not, (\i Let him be to 'the church'); because the discourse is of peculiar and private scandal against a single man; who, after three admonitions given, and they to no purpose, is freed from the law of brotherly obligation; and he who being admonished does not repent, is not to be esteemed so much for a brother to him, as for a heathen, etc.
\par\par I. Christ does not here prescribe concerning every offender, according to the full latitude of that law, (\cf11\ul Leviticus 19:17); but of him that particularly offends against his brother; and he does particularly teach what is to be done to that brother.
\par\par II. Although he, against whom the offence is committed, had a just cause, why he should be loosed from the obligation of the office of a brother towards him, who neither would make satisfaction for the wrong done, nor be admonished of it; yet to others in the church there is not the same reason.
\par\par III. The words plainly mean this; "If, after a threefold and just reproof, he that sinned against thee still remains untractable, and neither will give thee satisfaction for the injury, nor, being admonished, doth repent, thou hast delivered thine own soul, and art free from brotherly offices towards him"; just as the Jews reckon themselves freed from friendly offices towards (\i heathens) and (\i publicans). That of (\cf9\b Maimonides) is not much different: "A Jew that apostatizes, or breaks the sabbath presumptuously, is altogether like a (\i heathen)."
\par\par 1. They reckoned not (\i heathens) for brethren or neighbours: "If any one's ox shall gore his neighbour's ox: his neighbour's, not a (\i heathen's); when he saith (\i neighbour's); he excludes (\i heathens)." A quotation which we produced before.
\par\par 2. They reputed (\i publicans) to be by no means within religious society: (\i A religious man, who becomes a publican, is to be driven out of the society of religion).
\par\par 3. Hence they ate neither with (\i heathens) nor with (\i publicans); concerning which thing they often quarrel (\cf15\i [with]) our Saviour. Hence that of the apostle, (\cf11\ul 1 Corinthians 5:11); "With such an one no not to eat," is the same with what is spoke here, "Let him be to thee as a (\i heathen);" etc.
\par\par "It is forbidden a Jew to be alone with (\i a heathen); to travel with (\i a heathen);" etc.
\par\par 4. They denied also brotherly offices to (\i heathens) and (\i publicans); "It is forbidden to bring home any thing of a (\i heathen's) that is lost." "It is lawful for (\i publicans) to swear that is an oblation which is not; that you are of the king's retinue when you are not," etc. that is, (\i publicans) may deceive, and that by oath.
\par\par