11. And as for the cup belonging to the
mysteries, what was it, or where was it broken by Macarius? for this is
the report which they spread up and down. But as for Athanasius, even
his accusers would not have ventured to blame him, had they not been
suborned by them. However, they attribute the origin of the offence to
him; although it ought not to be imputed even to Macarius who is clear
of it. And they are not ashamed to parade the sacred mysteries before
Catechumens, and worse than that, even before heathens This
period, when Christianity was acknowledged by the state but not
embraced by the population, is just the time when we hear most of this
Reserve as a principle. While Christians were but a sect, persecution
enforced a discipline, and when they were commensurate with the nation,
faith made it unnecessary. We are now returned to the state of the
fourth century.: whereas, they ought to attend to what is
written, ‘It is good to keep close the secret of a king Tob. xii. 7.;’ and as the Lord has charged us,
‘Give not that which is holy unto the dogs, neither cast ye your
pearls before swine Matt. vii. 6..’ We ought not
then to parade the holy mysteries before the uninitiated, lest the
heathen in their ignorance deride them, and the Catechumens being
over-curious be offended. However, what was the cup, and where and
before whom was it broken? It is the Meletians who make the accusation,
who are not worthy of the least credit, for they have been schismatics
and enemies of the Church, not of a recent date, but from the times of
the blessed Peter, Bishop and Martyr [Cf.
§59, and Ep. Æg. 22, Prolegg. ch. ii. §2
init.]. They formed a
conspiracy against Peter himself; they calumniated his successor
Achillas; they accused Alexander even before the Emperor; and being
thus well versed in these arts, they have now transferred their enmity
to Athanasius, acting altogether in accordance with their former
wickedness. For as they slandered those that have been before him, so
now they have slandered him. But their calumnies and false accusations
have never prevailed against him until now, that they have got Eusebius
and his fellows for their assistants and patrons, on account of the
impiety which these have adopted from the Arian madmen, which has led
them to conspire against many Bishops, and among the rest
Athanasius.