Basil was also troubled with the continued
refusal of Athanasius and the Westerns to repudiate Marcellus, who was
still living in extreme old age, and to whom the mass of the people at
Ancyra were attached (Bas. Ep. 266, Legat. Eugen. 1, ἀναρίθμητον
πλῆθος). This state of things, he
urged, kept alive the prejudice of many against the Nicene decrees
(Ep. 69). But the Marcellians, perhaps aware of the efforts of
Basil, sent a deputation, headed by the deacon Eugenius, and fortified
by letters from ‘the bishops’ of Macedonia and Achaia, to
Alexandria. A synod was apparently in readiness to receive them, and
upon demand they produced a statement of their faith, emphatically
adopting the Nicene creed, condemning Sabellius, but affirming an ἐν
ὑποστάσει
τριάδα. The distinction between
Λόγος and the Son is
rejected, and the idea that the Monad existed before the Son
anathematised. Photinus is classed as a heretic with Paul of Samosata.
Only the eternal duration of Christ’s kingdom is not mentioned.
(It may be noted that while this letter gives up many points of the
theology of Marcellus, the process is quite completed in a letter
submitted by the Marcellian community in 375 to some exiled Egyptian
bishops at Diocæsarea For the
best treatment of the document, see Zahn, p, 95. I am quite unable to
follow the theory advanced in D. C. B. iii. 812; least of all the
writer’s suggestion that Athanasius was ‘egregiously
duped’ (!) by Marcellus.; Epiph.
Hær. 72, 11). Athanasius accepted the confession, and the
assembled bishops subscribed their names (only a few signatures are preserved). While we understand
Basil’s regret at the refusal of Athanasius to condemn Marcellus,
we can scarcely share it. If Athanasius shewed partiality toward his
old ally, it was an error of generosity, or rather let us say a
recognition of the truth, too often forgotten in religious controversy,
that mistakes are not necessarily heresies, and that a man may go very
far wrong in his opinions and yet be entitled to sympathy and
respect.