indefectible authority, which was subjected to synodical inquiry, and deliberation. What,
then, is the issue of this conflict, unless that it is equally evident that the letter was written
with the whole authority of the Apostolic See, and yet subjected, as usual, to the examination
of an Universal Council.
(Ib. LXI.)
And in this we follow no other authority than Leo himself, who speaks thus in his letter
to Theodoret: “What God had before decreed by our ministry, he confirmed by the irrevers-
ible assent of the whole brotherhood, to shew that what was first put forth in form by the
First See of all, and then received by the judgment of the whole Christian world, really pro-
ceeded from himself.” Here is a decree, as Baronius says, but not as Bellarmine says, an in-
struction: here is a judgment of the whole world upon a decree of the Apostolic See. He
proceeds: “For in order that the consent of other sees to that which the Lord of all appointed
to preside over the rest might not appear flattery, nor any other adverse suspicion creep in,
persons were at first found who doubted concerning our judgments.” And not only heretics,
246
but even the Fathers of the council themselves, as the acts bear witness. Here the First See
shews a fear of flattery, if doubt about its judgments were forbidden. Moreover, “The truth
itself likewise is both more clearly conspicuous, and more strongly maintained, when after
examination confirms what previous faith had taught.” Here in plain words he speaks of
an examination by the council, de fide, not by himself, as they wretchedly object, but of that
faith which the decretal letter set forth. And at length that same letter is issued as the Rule,
but confirmed by the assent of the universal holy Council, or as he had before said, after
that it is confirmed by the irreversible assent of the whole Brotherhood. Out of this expres-
sion of that great Pontiff, the Gallican clergy drew theirs, that in questions of faith the
judgment is, what Tertullian calls, “not to be altered;” what Leo calls, “not to be reconsidered,”
only when the assent of the Church is added.
(Defens. Dec. Cleri Gall. VII. xvij.)
This certainly no one can be blamed for holding with him and with the Fathers of
Chalcedon. The forma is set forth by the Apostolic See, yet it is to be received with a judg-
ment, and that free, and each bishop individually is inferior to the First, yet so that all together
pass judgment even on his decree.
They conceived no other way of removing all doubt; for, after the conclusion of the
synod, the Emperor thus proclaims: “Let then all profane contentions cease, for he is indeed
impious and sacrilegious, who, after the sentence of so many priests, leaves anything for his
own opinion to consider.” He then prohibits all discussion concerning religion; for, says
he, “he does an injury to the judgment of the most religious council, who endeavours to
open afresh, and publicly discuss, what has been once judged, and rightly ordered.” Here
in the condemnation of Eutyches is the order of Ecclesiastical judgments in questions of
faith. He is judged by his proper Bishop, Flavian: the cause is reheard, reconsidered by the
458
General Introduction.