Let us now set forth
Eunomius’ statement once more. “He was not,” he says,
“before His own generation.” Who is it of Whom he says
“He was not”? Let him declare the Divine names by which He
Who, according to Eunomius, “once was not,” is called. He
will say, I suppose, “light,” and
“blessedness,” “life” and
“incorruptibility,” and “righteousness” and
“sanctification,” and “power,” and
“truth,” and the like. He who says, then, that “He
was not before His generation,” absolutely proclaims
this,—that when He “was not” there was no truth, no
life, no light, no power, no incorruptibility, no other of those
pre-eminent qualities which are conceived of Him: and, what is still more
marvellous and still more difficult for impiety to face, there was no
“brightness,” no “express image.” For in saying
that there was no brightness, there is surely maintained also the
non-existence of the radiating power, as one may see in the
illustration afforded by the lamp. For he who speaks of the ray of the
lamp indicates also that the lamp shines, and he who says that the ray
“is not,” signifies also the extinction of that which gives
light: so that when the Son is said not to be, thereby is also
maintained as a necessary consequence the non-existence of the Father.
For if the one is related to the other by way of conjunction, according
to the Apostolic testimony—the “brightness” to the
“glory,” the “express image” to the
“Person,” the “Wisdom” to God—he who says
that one of the things so conjoined “is not,” surely by his
abolition of the one abolishes also that which remains; so that if the
“brightness” “was not,” it is acknowledged that
neither did the illuminating nature exist, and if the “express
image” had no existence, neither did the Person imaged exist, and
if the wisdom and power of God “was not,” it is surely
acknowledged that He also was not, Who is not conceived by Himself
without wisdom and power. If, then, the Only-begotten God, as Eunomius
says, “was not before His generation,” and Christ is
“the power of God and the wisdom of God 1 Cor. i. 24.,” and the “express image” Heb. i. 3. and the “brightness Heb. i. 3.,” neither surely did the Father exist,
Whose power and wisdom and express image and brightness the Son is: for
it is not possible to conceive by reason either a Person without
express image, or glory without radiance, or God without wisdom, or a
Maker without hands, or a Beginning without the Word Or
perhaps “or an irrational first cause,” (ἄλογον
ἀρχήν.),
or a Father without a Son; but all such things, alike by those who
confess and by those who deny, are manifestly declared to be in mutual
union, and by the abolition of one the other also disappears with it.
Since then they maintain that the Son (that is, the “brightness
of the glory,”) “was not” before He was begotten, and
since logical consequence involves also, together with the
non-existence of the brightness, the abolition of the glory, and the
Father is the glory whence came the brightness of the Only-begotten
Light, let these men who are wise over-much consider that they are
manifestly supporters of the Epicurean doctrines, preaching atheism
under the guise of Christianity. Now since the logical consequence is
shown to be one of two absurdities, either that we should say that God
does not exist at all, or that we should say that His being was not
unoriginate, let them choose which they like of the two courses before
them,—either to be called atheist, or to cease saying that the
essence of the Father is un-originate. They would avoid, I suppose,
being reckoned atheists. It remains, therefore, that they maintain that
God is not eternal. And if the course of what has been proved forces
them to this, what becomes of their varied and irreversible conversions
of names? What becomes of that invincible compulsion of their
syllogisms, which sounded so fine to the ears of old women, with its
opposition of “Generated” and
“Ungenerate”?