Chapter 57.—69. Furthermore, if, while I have continued without intermission to prove
how entirely the passages of Scripture which Petilianus has quoted against us have failed to
hurt our cause, he himself has in some cases not touched at all what I have quoted, and
partly, when he has endeavored to handle them, has shown that the only thing that he could
do was to fail in finding an escape from them, you require no long exhortation or advice in
order to see what you ought to maintain, and what you should avoid. But it may be that
this has been the kind of show that he has made in dealing with the testimony of holy
Scripture, but that he has not been without force in the case of the documentary evidence
found in the records of the schism itself. Let us then see in the case of these too, though it
is superfluous to inquire into them after testimony from the word of God, what he has
quoted, or what he has proved. For, after pouring forth a violent invective against traditors,
and quoting loudly many passages against them from the holy books themselves, he yet said
nothing which could prove his opponents to be traditors. But I quoted the case of Silvanus
of Cirta, who held his own see some little time before himself, who was expressly declared
in the Municipal Chronicles to have been a traditor while he was yet a sub-deacon. Against
this fact he did not venture to whisper a syllable. And yet you cannot fail to see how strong
the pressure was which must have been urging him to reply that he might show a man, who
was his predecessor, not only one of his party, but a partner, so to speak, in his see, to have
been innocent of the crime of delivering up the sacred books, especially as you rest the whole
strength of your cause on the fact that you give the name of traditor to all whom you either
pretend or believe to have been the successors of traditors in the path of their communion.
Although, then, the very exigencies of your cause would seem to compel him to undertake
627
the defence of a citizen even of Russicadia, or Calama, or any other city of your party, whom
I should declare to be a traditor, on the authority of the Municipal Chronicles, yet he did
not open his mouth even in defense of his own predecessor. For what reason, except that
he could not find any mist dark enough to deceive the minds of even the slowest and
sleepiest of men? For what could he have said, except that the charges brought against Sil-
vanus were false? But we quote the words of the Chronicles, both as to the date of the fact,
and as to the time of the information laid before Zenophilus the ex-consul.2462 And how
could he resist this evidence, being encompassed on every side by the most excellent cause
of the Catholics, while yours was bad as bad could be? For which reason I quote these words
from my epistle to which he would fain be thought to have replied in this which I am now
refuting, that you may see for yourselves how impregnable the position must be against
which he has been able to find no safer weapon than silence.
2462 See Book III. c. Cresconium, cc. 27, 28, 31, 32.
Chapter 57
1252
Chapter 57