326 JEROME.
say, he sincerely believed in the Father, and
the Son, and the Holy Ghost, and therefore
obtained baptism, what, let me ask, is the
meaning of being sincerely ignorant of what
one believes ? He sincerely believed. What
did he believe ? Surely when he heard the
three names, he believed in three Gods, and
was an idolater ; or by the three titles he was
led to believe in a God with three names, and
so fell into the ' Sabellian heresy. Or he was perhaps trained by the Arians to believe that
there is one true God, the Father, but that the
Son and the Holy Spirit are creatures. What
else he may have believed, I know not : for
we can hardly think that a man brought up in
the Capitol would have learnt the doctrine of
the co-essential Trinity. He would have
known in that case that the Father, Son, and
Holy Spirit are not divided in nature, but in
person. He would have known also that the
name of Son was implied in that of Father and
the name of Father in that of Son. It is ridic-
ulous to assert that any one can dispute con-
cerning the faith before he believes it ; that
he understands a mystery before he has been
initiated ; that the baptizer and the baptized
hold different views respecting God. Besides,
it is the custom at baptism to ask, after the
confession of faith in the Trinity, do you be-
lieve in Holy Church ? Do you believe in the
remission of sins ? What Church do you say he believed in ? The Church of the Arians ? But
they have no Church. In ours ? But the man
was not baptized into it : he could not believe
in that whereof he was ignorant.
L. I see that you can prattle cleverly about
each point that I raise ; and when we let fly a
dart you elude it by a harangue which serves
you for a shield ; I will therefore hurl a single
spear which will be strong enough to pierce
your defences and the hail-storm of your
words. I won't allow strength any longer to be overcome by artifice. Even a layman bap-
tized without the Church, if he be baptized
according to the faith, is received only as a
penitent : but a bishop either does no penance
and remains a bishop, or, if he does penance
he ceases to be a bishop. Wherefore we do
right both in welcoming the penitent layman,
and in rejecting the bishop, if he wishes to continue in his office.
O. An arrow which is discharged from the
tight-drawn bow is not easy to avoid, for it reaches him at whom it was aimed before the
shield can be raised to stop it. On the other
1 This was, approximately, the Patripassian form of the heresy, according to which the person of the Father who is one with the
Son, was incarnate in Christ, and the Father might then be said
to have died upon the cross. The personality of the Holy Ghost
appears to have been denied. With varying shades of opinion
and modes of expression the doctrine was expounded by Praxeas (circ. A. D. 200), Noetius < A. D. 220), Sabellius (A. D.
225), Beryllus and Paul of Samosata (circ. A. D. 250).
hand your propositions are pointless and there-
fore cannot pierce an opponent. The spear then
which you have hurled with all your might and
about which you speak such threatening words,
I turn aside, as the saying is, with my little
finger. The point in dispute is not merely
whether a bishop is incapable of penitence and
a layman capable, but whether a heretic has
received valid baptism. If he has not (and
this follows from your position), how can he
be a penitent, before he is a Christian ? Show
me that a layman coming from the Arians has
valid baptism, and then I will not deny him
penitence. But if he is not a Christian, if he
had no priest to make him a Christian, how
can he do penance when he is not yet a be- liever ?
14. L. I beseech you lay aside the methods
of the philosophers and let us talk with Chris-
tian simplicity ; that is, if you are willing to
follow not the logicians, but the Galilean
fishermen. Does it seem right to you that an
Arian should be a bishop ?
O. You prove him a bishop because
you receive those he has baptized. And
it is here that you are to blame : — Why
are there walls of separation between us
when we are at one in faith and in receiving Arians ?
L. I asked you before not to talk like a phi-
losopher, but like a Christian.
O. Do you wish to learn, or to argue ?
L. Of course I argue because I want to
know the reason for what you do.
O. If you argue, you have already had an
answer. I receive an Arian bishop for the
same reason that you receive a person who is
only baptized. If you wish to learn, come
over to my side : for an opponent must be
overcome, it is only a disciple who can be
taught.
L. Before I can be a disciple, I must hear
one preach whom I feel to be my master.
O. You are not dealing quite fairly : you
wish me to be your teacher on the terms that
you may treat me as an opponent whenever
you please. I will teach you therefore in the
same spirit. We agree in faith, we agree in
receiving heretics, let us also be at one in our
terms of communion.
L. That is not teaching, but arguing.
O. As you ask for peace with a shield in
your hand, I also must carry my olive branch
with a sword grafted in it.
L. I drop my hands in token of submission.
You are conqueror. But in laying down my
arms, I ask the meaning of the oath you force me to take.
O. Certainly, but first I congratulate you,
and thank Christ my God for your good dis-
positions which have made you turn from the