These persons can hardly have rejected the Law and the Prophets
utterly,—at least, no hint is given us that they maintained a
fundamental difference between the God of the Old and the God of the
New Testament, as Marcion did,—nor would such wholesale rejection
be natural for critics such as they were. It is more likely that they
simply, as many of the Gnostics did, emphasized the merely relative
authority of the Old Testament, and that they applied historical
criticism to it, distinguishing between its various parts in the matter
of authority. Such action is just what we should expect from members of
a critical school like that of Theodotus, and such criticism in its
extremest form would naturally seem to an orthodox Catholic the same as
throwing over the whole book. Cf. Harnack, Dogmengeschicte, p.
579 and p. 488 sqq.