17. This is of itself a sufficient refutation of
the Arian heresy; however, its heterodoxy will appear also from the
following:—If God be Maker and Creator, and create His works
through the Son, and we cannot regard things which come to be, except
as being through the Word, is it not blasphemous, God being Maker, to
say, that His Framing Word and His Wisdom once was not? it is the same
as saying, that God is not Maker, if He had not His proper Framing Word
which is from Him, but that that by which He frames, accrues to Him
from without de
Decr. 25, note 2., and is alien from Him, and unlike in
essence. Next, let them tell us this,—or rather learn from it how
irreligious they are in saying, ‘Once He was not,’ and,
‘He was not before His generation;’—for if the Word
is not with the Father from everlasting, the Triad is not everlasting;
but a Monad was first, and afterwards by addition it became a Triad;
and so as time went on, it seems what we know concerning God grew and
took shape Vid.
Orat. iv. §13.. And further, if the Son is not proper
offspring of the Father’s essence, but of nothing has come to be,
then of nothing the Triad consists, and once there was not a Triad, but
a Monad; and a Triad once with deficiency, and then complete;
deficient, before the Son was originated, complete when He had come to
be; and henceforth a thing originated is reckoned with the Creator, and
what once was not has divine worship and glory with Him who was ever §8, note 8.. Nay, what is more serious still, the Triad
is discovered to be unlike Itself, consisting of strange and alien
natures and essences. And this, in other words, is saying, that the
Triad has an originated consistence. What sort of a religion then is
this, which is not even like itself, but is in process of completion as
time goes on, and is now not thus, and then again thus? For probably it
will receive some fresh accession, and so on without limit, since at
first and at starting it took its consistence by way of accessions. And
so undoubtedly it may decrease on the contrary, for what is added
plainly admits of being subtracted.