“Therefore also they disagree among themselves, maintaining an inconsistent opin-
ion.1540 For Apelles,1541 one of the herd, priding himself on his manner of life1542 and his
1540 The Fathers entirely misunderstood Marcion, and mistook the significance of his movement. They re-
garded it, like Gnosticism in general, solely as a speculative system, and entirely overlooked its practical aim.
The speculative and theological was not the chief thing with Marcion, but it is the only thing which receives any
attention from his opponents. His positions, all of which were held only with a practical interest, were not treated
by him in a speculative manner, nor were they handled logically and systematically. As a consequence, many
contradictions occur in them. These contradictions were felt by his followers, who laid more and more emphasis
upon the speculative over against the practical; and hence, as Rhodo reports, they fell into disagreement, and,
in their effort to remove the inconsistencies, formed various schools, differing among themselves according to
the element upon which the greatest weight was laid. There is thus some justification for the conduct of the
Fathers, who naturally carried back and attributed to Marcion the principles of his followers. But it is our duty
to distinguish the man from his followers, and to recognize his greatness in spite of their littleness. Not all of
them, however, fell completely away from his practical religious spirit. Apelles, as we shall see below, was in
many respects a worthy follower of his master.
1541 Apelles was the greatest and most famous of Marcion’s disciples. Tertullian wrote a special work against
him, which is unfortunately lost, but from his own quotations, and from those of Pseudo-Tertullian and Hip-
polytus, it can be in part restored (cf. Harnack’s De Apellis Gnosis Monarchia, p. 11 sqq.). As he was an old man
(see §5, below) when Rhodo conversed with him, he must have been born early in the second century. We know
nothing definite either as to his birth or death. The picture which we have of him in this chapter is a very
pleasing one. He was a man evidently of deep religious spirit and moral life, who laid weight upon “trust in the
crucified Christ” (see §5, below), and upon holiness in life in distinction from doctrinal beliefs; a man who was
thus thoroughly Marcionitic in his principles, although he differed so widely with Marcion in some of his doc-
trinal positions that he was said to have founded a new sect (so Origen, Hom. in Gen. II. 2). The slightest difference,
however, between his teaching and Marcion’s would have been sufficient to make him the founder of a separate
Gnostic sect in the eyes of the Fathers, and therefore this statement must be taken with allowance (see note 4,
above). The account which Hippolytus (Phil. X. 16) gives of the doctrinal positions of Apelles is somewhat dif-
ferent from that of Rhodo, but ambiguous and less exact. The scandal in regard to him, reported by Tertullian
in his De Præscriptione, 30, is quite in accord with Tertullian’s usual conduct towards heretics, and may be set
aside as not having the slightest foundation in fact, and as absolutely contradicting what we know of Apelles
from this report of his contemporary, Rhodo. His moral character was certainly above reproach, and the same
may be said of his master, Marcion. Upon Apelles, see especially Harnack’s De Apellis Gnosis Monarchia, Lips.
1874.
1542 The participle (σεμνυνόμενος) carries with it the implication that Apelles’ character was affected or as-
sumed. The implication, however, does not lessen the value of Rhodo’s testimony to his character. He could not
deny its purity, though he insinuated that it was not sincere.
534
Rhodo and his Account of the Dissension of Marcion.