SECT. III.
Instances of the third thing observed in Mr. W.‘s manner of arguing, viz. His pretending
to oppose and answer arguments, by saying things which have no reference to them, but relate
to other matters, perfectly foreign to the subject of the argument.
Such is his answer (p. 37, &c.) to my argument from Isa. lvi. Particularly from those
words, Isaiah lvi. 6, 7. “Also the sons, of the stranger, that join themselves to the Lord, to
serve him, to love the name of the Lord, to be his servants,—even them will I bring to my
512
holy mountain, and make them joyful in my house of prayer,” &c. For I say nothing under
that argument, (as Mr. W. in his answer presumes,) which supposes any antithesis or oppos-
ition here between the state of the Gentiles and eunuchs under the Old Testament, and under
the gospel, as to terms of acceptance with God: nor any opposition, as to a greater necessity
of sanctifying grace, to the lawful partaking of ordinances, under the gospel, than under the
law; as Mr. W. also supposes in his arguings on this head. But the opposition I speak of, as
plainly pointed forth in the chapter, is this: That whereas under the law, not only piety of
heart and practice were required, but something else, even soundness of body and circum-
cision, it is foretold, that under the gospel, piety of heart and practice only should be required;
that although they were eunuchs or uncircumcised, yet if it appeared that they loved the
name of the Lord, &c. they should be admitted.
So when I argued, that Christ, in the latter part of the 7th chap. of Matt.. representing
the final issue of things, with regard to the visible church in general, speaks of all as those
who had looked on themselves to be interested in him as their Lord and Saviour, and had
an opinion of their good estate; though the hope of some was built on the sand, and others
on a rock:—Mr. W. in his reply, (p. 40, 41.) entirely overlooks the argument, and talks about
other things. He says, Christ does not find fault with those that cried, Lord, Lord, for entering
into covenant, but for not keeping covenant, (p. 41. b.) Here he runs back to another thing,
relating to another argument, to which this has no reference, which he dwells wholly upon;
and says nothing to the argument I use in that place.
So in his reply to what I say on the parable of the wheat and tares, (p. 98, &c.) he has
entirely overlooked the argument. He says, to vindicate the objection, (p. 99.) “Which we
think shows us the mind and will of Christ in this matter is, that his servants shall proceed
only on certain established rules of his visible kingdom, and not upon any private rules of
judging about them.”—Whereas, I never said, or supposed, that Christ’s servants must not
proceed on certain established rules of his visible kingdom, or that they ought to go upon any
private rules of judging; but particularly and largely expressed my mind to the contrary, in
explaining the question; (Inq. p. 5.) “That it is properly a visibility to the eye of the public
charity, and not of a private judgment, that gives a right to be received as visible saints by
the public.” And repeat the same thing again, p. 125. c. d.
SECTION III. Irrelevant arguments.
1975
SECTION III. Irrelevant arguments.