Lastly, it must again be insisted that in his
polemic against Arianism Athanasius is centrally soteriological. It is
unnecessary to collect passages in support of what will be fully
appreciated only after a thorough study of the controversial treatises.
The essence of his position is comprised in his paraphrase of St.
Peter’s address to the Jews, Orat. ii. 16, sq., or
in the argument, ib. 67, sqq., i. 43, and iii. 13. With
regard to the Incarnation, it may be admitted that Athanasius uses
language which might have been modified had he had later controversies
in view. His common use of ἄνθρωπος for the Manhood
of Christ (see below, p. 83) might be alleged by the Nestorian, his
comparison of it to the vesture of the High Priest (Orat. i. 47,
ii. 8, see note there) by the Apollinarian or Monophysite partisan. But
at least his use of either class of expressions shews that he did not
hold the doctrine associated in later times with the other. Moreover,
while from first to last he is explicitly clear as to the seat of
personality in Christ, which is uniformly assigned to the Divine Logos
(p. 40, note 2 and reff.), the
integrity of the manhood of Christ is no less distinctly asserted (cf.
de Incarn. 18. 1, 21. 7). He uses σῶμα and ἄνθρωπος indifferently
during the earlier stages of the conflict, ignoring or failing to
notice the peculiarity of the Luciano-Arian Christology. But from 362
onward the full integrity of the Saviour’s humanity, σὰρξ and ψυχὴ
λογικὴ or πνεῦμα, is energetically
asserted against the theory of Apollinarius and those akin to it The
doctrine of Athanasius is, not formally but none the less really, the
doctrine of Chalcedon, which again stands or falls together with that
of Nicæa. Like the latter, it transcends the power of human
thought to do more than state it in terms which exclude the (Nestorian
and Monophysite) alternatives. The Man Jesus Christ is held to have
lacked nothing that constitutes personality in man; the human
personality which therefore belongs to it ideally, being in
fact merged in the Divine personality of the Son. The
‘impersonality,’ as it is sometimes called, of
Christ quâ man is therefore better spoken of as His
Divine Personality. Personality and will are correlated but not
identical ideas. (cf. Letters 59 and 60, and c.
Apoll.). Some corollaries of this doctrine must now be
mentioned.