But, like a mighty wrestler, he
will not relinquish his irresistible hold on us, and affirms in so many
words, that “these names are the work of human thought and
conception, and that, by the exercise of this operation of the mind by
some, results are arrived at which no Apostle or Evangelist has
taught.” And after this doughty onslaught he raises that
sanctimonious voice of his, spitting out his foul abuse at us with a
tongue well schooled to such language. “For,” says he,
“to ascribe homonyms, drawn from analogy, to human thought and
conception is the work of a mind that has lost all judicial sense, and
that studies the words of the Lord with an enfeebled understanding and
dishonest habit of thought.” Mercy on us! what a logical
argument! how scientifically it proceeds to its conclusion! Who after
this will dare to speak up for the cause of conception, when such a
stench is poured forth from his mouth upon those who attempt speaking?
I suppose, then, that we, who do attempt speaking, must forbear to
examine his argument, for fear of his stirring up against us the
cesspool of his abuse. And verily it is weak-minded ῏Η μικροψύχων
κ.τ.λ. Oehler’s stopping
here (and accent) is better than that of the Codices.
i.e. ὑποκινήσειεν,
ἢ κ.τ.λ. to let ourselves be irritated by childish
absurdities. We will therefore allow our insolent adversary full
liberty to indulge in his method as he will. But we will return to the
Master’s argument, that thence too we may muster reinforcements
for the truth. Eunomius has been reminded of “analogy” and
has perceived “the homonyms to be derived from it.” Now
where or from whom did he learn these terms? Not from Moses, not from
the Prophets and Apostles, not from the Evangelists. It is impossible
that he should have learned them from the teaching of any Scripture.
How came he, then, to use them? The very word which describes this or
that signification of a thought as analogy, is it not the invention of
the thinking faculty of him who utters it In
other words, analogy implies thought (λόγος).?
How is it, then, that he fails to perceive that he is using the views
he fights against as his allies in the war? For he makes war against
our principle of words being formed by the operation of conception, and
would endeavour to establish, by the aid of words formed on that very
principle, that it is unlawful to use them. “It is not,”
says he, “the teaching of any of the sacred writers.” To
whom, then, of the ancients do you yourself ascribe the term
“ungenerate,” and its being predicated of the essence of
God? or is it allowable for you, when you want to establish some of
your impious conclusions, to coin and invent terms to your own liking;
but if anything is said by some one else in contravention of your
impiety, to deprive your adversary of similar licence? Great indeed
would be the power you would assume if you could make good your claim
to such authority as this, that what you refuse to others should be
allowable to you alone, and that what you yourself presume to do by
virtue of it, you should prevent others from doing. You condemn, as by
an edict, the doctrine that these names were applied to Christ as a
result of conception, because none of the sacred writers have declared
that they ought so to be applied. How, then, can you lay down the law
that the Divine essence should be denoted by the word
“ungenerate”—a term which none of the sacred writers
can be
shown to have handed down to us? For if this is the test of the right
use of words, that only such shall be employed as the inspired word of
Scripture shall authorize, the word “ungenerate” must be
erased from your own writings, since none of the sacred writers has
sanctioned the expression. But perhaps you accept it by reason of the
sense that resides in it. Well, we ourselves in the same way accept the
term “conception” by reason of the sense that resides in
it. Accordingly we will either exclude both from use, or neither, and
whichever alternative be adopted, we are equally masters of the field.
For if the term “ungenerate” be altogether suppressed, all
our adversaries’ clamour against the truth is suppressed along
with it, and a doctrine worthy of the Only-begotten Son of God will
shine forth, inasmuch as logical opposition can furnish no name i.e.no other name. See note on
᾽Αγέννητος, p. 100. to detract from the majesty of the Lord. But
if both be retained, in that case also the truth will prevail, and we
along with it, when we have altered the word “ungeneracy”
from the substance, into a conception, of the Deity. But so long as he
does not exclude the term “ungenerate” from his own
writings, let our modern Pharisee admonish himself not to behold the
mote that is in our eye, before he has cast out the beam that is in his
own.