It is said, there can be no reason assigned, why unsanctified persons may attend other
duties of worship, and not the Lord’s supper. But I humbly conceive this must be an inad-
vertence. For there is a reason very obvious from that necessary and very notable distinction
among duties of worship, which follows:
1. There are some duties of worship, that imply a profession of God’s covenant; whose
very nature and design is an exhibition of those vital active principles and inward exercises,
wherein consists the condition of the covenant of grace, or that union of soul to God, which
is the union between Christ and his spouse, entered into by an inward hearty consenting to
that covenant. Such are the christian sacraments, whose very design is to make and confirm
a profession of compliance with that covenant, and whose very nature is to exhibit or express
the uniting acts of the soul: those sacramental duties therefore cannot be attended by any
whose hearts do not really consent to that covenant, and whose souls do not truly close with
Christ, without either their being self-deceived, or else wilfully making a false profession,
and lying in a very aggravated manner.
2. There are other duties, which are not in their own nature an exhibition of a covenant-
union with God, or of any compliance with the condition of the covenant of grace; but are
the expression of general virtues, or virtues in their largest extent, including both special
and common. Thus prayer, or asking mercy of God, is in its own nature no profession of a
compliance with the covenant of grace. It is an expression of some belief of the being of a
God, some sense of our wants, and of a need of God’s help, some sense of our dependence,
&c. but not merely such a sense of these things as is spiritual and saving. Indeed there are
some prayers proper to be made by saints, and many things proper to be expressed by them
in prayer, which imply the profession of a spiritual union of heart to God through Christ;
but such as no heathen, no heretic, nor natural man whatever, can or ought to make. Prayer
in general, and asking mercy and help from God, is no more a profession of consent to the
covenant of grace, than reading the Scriptures, or meditation, or performing any duty of
morality and natural religion. A Mahometan may as well ask mercy, as hear instruction:
and any natural man may as well express his desires to God, as hear when God declares his
will to him. It is true, when an unconverted man prays, the manner of his doing it is sinful:
but when a natural man, knowing himself to be so, comes to the Lord’s supper, the very
matter of what he does, in respect of the profession he there makes, and his pretension to
lay hold of God’s covenant, is a lie, and a lie told in the most solemn manner.
In a word, the venerable Mr. Stoddard himself, in his Doctrine of Instituted Churches,
has taught us to distinguish between instituted and natural acts of religion: the word and
prayer he places under the head of moral duty, and considers as common to all; but the
sacraments, according to what he says there, being instituted, are of special administration,
and must be limited agreeable to the institution.
1857
OBJ. XI. All duties of worship holy.