§6. Religious Characteristics.
Was Constantine a Christian? This vain question has to be considered, hardly discussed.
The interminable opinions, one way or the other, are for the most part wise-seeming,
meaningless generalizations. Like any generalized statement, it is conditioned by the point
of view of the author. When ten men answered the question “What is a Christian?” in ten
431
different ways, who shall say what any one is? This has been the difficulty. One does not
conceive of Christianity apart from baptismal regeneration. The question has then narrowed
to one of baptism. Constantine was not a Christian until just before his death. Another has
some other test. Another is not a Christian himself, and so on. A good Biblical, Protestant
starting-point is to say he was a Christian as soon as he believed in Christ, and that the
evidence of faith is in confession and action. Already, before his campaign into Italy, he
seems to have been in intimate contact with the Christians. Hosius was probably already
one of his advisers. The young emperor had inherited his father’s piety (Paneg. 307, c. 5),
and was inclined to monotheism. The words of advisers must have made him think at least,
and he seems to have made a sort of test of believing at the time of the famous “vision of
the cross,” whatever that may have been. Judging from the way men think and feel their
way to faith, it seems psychologically probable that, feeling his way along to that point, he
tried faith and, having success, he substantially believed from that time on. Certainly from
a very early period after this, the evidences begin to be clear and increasingly so as presumably
his faith itself became more clear and fixed. The account in Eusebius of the process of thought
by which he inclined toward Christianity has the greatest plausibility. He says that “consid-
ering the matter of Divine assistance, it occurred to him that those who had relied on idols
had been deceived and destroyed, while his father…had honored the one Supreme God,
had found him Saviour, &c.…he judged it folly to join in the idle worship of those who were
no gods…and felt it incumbent on him to honor no other than the God of his father.” The
nature of the vision of the cross, whether a miracle, a natural phenomenon, or only a dream,
does not affect the probability of the account by Eusebius of what followed it (V. C. 1. 32).
“At the time above specified, being struck with amazement at the extraordinary vision, and
resolving to worship no other God save him who had appeared to him, he sent for those
who were acquainted with the mysteries of his doctrines, and inquired also what God
was.…They affirmed that he was God, the only begotten Son of the one and only God,” and
he thereupon “made the priests of God his counsellors and deemed it incumbent on him
to honor the God who had appeared to him, with all devotion.” According to Sozomen, “it
is universally admitted Constantine embraced the religion of the Christians previous to his
war with Maxentius and prior to his return to Rome and Italy; and this is evidenced by the
dates of the laws which he enacted in favor of religion” (Soz. 1. 5; cf. 1. 3). Philostorgius (1.
6), “in conformity with all other writers,” ascribes to the victory over Maxentius (Photius.
Epit.). This is confirmed, too, by the remark of the Panegyrist (313, c. 4; cf. c. 2 and c. 11),
Religious Characteristics.
1075
Religious Characteristics.