of his procedure to his Lord.” What say you to that, brother Vincentius? Surely you must
see that this great man, this peace-loving bishop and dauntless martyr, made nothing more
earnestly his care than to prevent the sundering of the bond of unity. You see him travailing
in birth for the souls of men, not only that they might, when conceived, be born in Christ,
but also that, when born, they might not perish through their being shaken out of their
mother’s bosom.
42. Now give attention, I pray you, further to this thing which he has mentioned in
protesting against impious schismatics. If those who granted peace to adulterers, who repen-
397
ted of their sin, shared the guilt of adulterers, were those who did not so act defiled by fel-
lowship with them as colleagues in office? If, again, it was a right thing, as truth asserts and
the Church maintains, that peace should be given to adulterers who repented of their sin,
those who utterly closed against adulterers the door of reconciliation through repentance
were unquestionably guilty of impiety in refusing healing to the members of Christ, in taking
away the keys of the Church from those who knocked for admission, and in opposing with
heartless cruelty God’s most compassionate forbearance, which permitted them to live in
order that, repenting, they might be healed by the sacrifice of a contrite spirit and broken
heart. Nevertheless this their heartless error and impiety did not defile the others, compas-
sionate and peace-loving men, when these shared with them in the Christian sacraments,
and tolerated them within the net of unity, until the time when, brought to the shore, they
should be separated from each other; or if this error and impiety of others did defile them,
then the Church was already at that time destroyed, and there was no Church to give Cyp-
rian birth. But if, as is beyond question, the Church continued in existence, it is also beyond
question that no man in the unity of Christ can be stained by the guilt of the sins of other
men if he be not consenting to the deeds of the wicked, and thus defiled by actual particip-
ation in their crimes, but only, for the sake of the fellowship of the good, tolerating the
wicked, as the chaff which lies until the final purging of the Lord’s threshing-floor. These
things being so, where is the pretext for your schism? Are ye not an “evil generation, esteem-
ing yourselves righteous, yet not washed from the guilt of your going forth” [from the
Church]?
43. If, now, I were disposed to quote anything against you from the writings of Tychonius,
a man of your communion, who has written rather in defence of the Church and against
you than the reverse, in vain disowning the communion of African Christians as traditors
(by which one thing Parmenianus silences him), what else can you say in reply than what
Tychonius himself said of you as I have shortly before reminded you: “That which is accord-
ing to our will is holy”?2261 For this Tychonius—a man, as I have said, of your commu-
nion—writes that a Council was held at Carthage2262 by two hundred and seventy of your
2261 P. 387.
2262 This Council at Carthage is not elsewhere mentioned.
873
To Vincentius