I answered this argument in the second place, by alleging, that this doctrine of the ne-
cessity of saving grace in order to a right to the Lord’s supper, is not properly the cause of
the perplexities of doubting saints, in their attendance on this ordinance; though it may be
the occasion: but that their own negligence and sin is the true cause; and that this doctrine
is no more the cause of these perplexities, than the doctrine of the necessity of saving grace
in order to salvation, is the cause of the perplexity of doubting saints when they come to
die. Upon which Mr. W. says, There is no shadow of resemblance of these cases, because
death is no ordinance, &c. But if death is no ordinance, yet it is the required duty of the
saints to yield themselves to the Lord, and resign to the will of God, in their death. And in
this respect, the cases are exactly parallel, that perplexities are just so much the consequence
of the respective doctrines, in one case, as in the other; that is, the perplexities of a doubting
saint on a death-bed, the difficulty and trouble he meets with in resigning himself to the will
of God in dying, is just in the same manner the consequence of the doctrine of the necessity
of saving grace in order to eternal salvation, as the perplexities of a doubting saint at the
Lord’s table are the consequence of the doctrine of the necessity of saving grace in order to
a right to the Lord’s supper. And this is sufficient for my purpose.
Mr. W. himself says, in his answer to Mr. Croswell, (p. 122. c.) “Although there are
comparatively few that obtain assurance; yet it is through their own sloth and negligence
that they do not. We fully agree with Mr. Perkins, that a man in this life may ordinarily be
infallibly certain of his salvation. So Mr. Stoddard (in his sermon on one good sign—) says,
“There is no necessity, that the people of God should lie under darkness and temptation;
they may obtain assurance.”—Now, if this be the case, then certainly there is no justice in
laying the temptation and uneasiness, which is the effect of sloth and negligence, to the
doctrine I maintain, in those that embrace it. It is a wise dispensation of God, that he has
so ordered things, that comfort in ordinances, and in all duties, and under all providences,
should be to be obtained in a way of diligence; and that slothfulness should be the way to
perplexity and uneasiness, and should be a way hedged up with thorns, agreeable to Prov.
xv. 19.—That it is so ordered, is for the good of the saints, as it tends to turn them out of
this thorny path, into the way of diligence. And so this doctrine, as it has this tendency, has
a tendency in the end to that solid peace and comfort, which is the happy fruit of their holy
diligence. And that, and not the saints’ perplexity, is properly the effect of this doctrine.
2024
SECTION XVI. Tendency to perplexity.