Perhaps none of the canons of this synod present greater
and more insolvable difficulties than the present. It has been
for long centuries the tradition of the Church that the marriage of a
baptized Christian with an unbaptized person is null, but this canon
seems to say that the same is the case if the one party be a heretic
even though baptized. If this is what the canon means it elevates
heresy into an impedimentum dirimens. Such is not and
never has been the law of the West, and such is not to-day the practice
of the Eastern church, which allows the marriage of its people with
Lutherans and with Roman Catholics and never questions the validity of
their marriages. Van Espen thinks “the Greek commentators
seem” to think that the heretics referred to are unbaptized; I do
not know exactly why he thinks so.