3. So, then, if these things are so, we desire to learn this, first, from you—what is the
cause, what the reason, that you offer them sacrifices; and then, what gain comes to the gods
themselves from this, and remains to their advantage. For whatever is done should have a
cause, and should not be disjoined from reason, so as to be lost4778 among useless works,
and tossed about among vain and idle uncertainties.4779 Do the gods of heaven4780 live on
these sacrifices, and must materials be supplied to maintain the union of their parts? And
what man is there so ignorant of what a god is, certainly, as to think that they are maintained
by any kind of nourishment, and that it is the food given to them4781 which causes them to
live and endure throughout their endless immortality? For whatever is upheld by causes
and things external to itself, must be mortal and on the way to destruction, when anything
on which it lives begins to be wanting. Again, it is impossible to suppose that any one believes
519
this, because we see that of these things which are brought to their altars, nothing is added
to and reaches the substance of the deities; for either incense is given, and is lost melting on
the coals,4782 or the life only of the victim is offered to the gods,4783 and its blood is licked
up by dogs; or if any flesh is placed upon the altars, it is set on fire in like manner, and is
destroyed, and falls into ashes,—unless perchance the god seizes upon the souls of the victims,
or snuffs up eagerly the fumes and smoke which rise from the blazing altars, and feeds upon
the odours which the burning flesh gives forth, still wet with blood, and damp with its former
juices.4784 But if a god, as is said, has no body, and cannot be touched at all, how is it possible
that that which has no body should be nourished by things pertaining to the body,—that
what is mortal should support what is immortal, and assist and give vitality to that which
4778 The ms. and edd. read ut in operibus feratur cassis—“so as to be borne among,” emended by Hild. and
Oehler teratur—“worn away among.”
4779 Lit., “in vain errors of inanity.”
4780 The ms. and edd. have here forte—“perchance.’”
4781 Lit., “gift of food.”
4782 [It must have taken much time to overcome this distaste for the use of incense in Christian minds. Let
us wait for the testimony of Lactantius.]
4783 Or perhaps, simply, “the sacrifice is a living one,” animalis est hostia. Macrobius, however (Sat., iii. 5),
quotes Trebatius as saying that there were two kinds of sacrifices, in one of which the entrails were examined
that they might disclose the divine will, while in the other the life only was consecrated to the deity. This is more
precisely stated by Servius (Æn., iii. 231), who says that the hostia animalis was only slain, that in other cases
the blood was poured on the altars, that in others part of the victim, and in others the whole animal, was burned.
It is probable, therefore that Arnobius uses the words here in their technical meaning, as the next clause shows
that none of the flesh was offered, while the blood was allowed to fall to the ground. [I am convinced that clas-
sical antiquities must be more largely studied in the Fathers of the first five centuries.]
4784 i.e., the juices which formerly flowed through the living body.
Chapter III.
1260
Chapter III.