124 THE SEVEN BOOKS OF [Boox rr.
not dare to overthrow, to destroy,' from love of contradiction,
although that which they attempt to invalidate is unobjection-
able? and manifest, and evidently bears the stamp of truth ?
Or what, again, can they not maintain with plausible argu-
ments, although it may be very manifestly untrue, although
it may be a plain and evident falsehood? For when a man
has persuaded himself that there is or is not something, he
likes to affirm what he thinks, and to show greater subtlety
than others, especially if the subject discussed is out of the
ordinary track, and by nature abstruse and obscure, Some
of the wise think that the world was not created, and will
never perish;* some that it is immortal, although they say
that it was created and made;° while a third party have
chosen to say that it both was created and made, and will
perish as other things must And while of these three
opinions one only must be true, they nevertheless all find
arguments by which at once to uphold their own doctrines,
and undermine and overthrow the dogmas of others. Some
teach and declare that this same [world] is composed of four
elements, others of two,’ a third party of one; some say that
1 So the Ms., reading labefactare dissolvere ; the latter word, however,
being marked as spurious.
2 Lit., ** pure.”
§ Lit., * hidden and enwrapt in darkness of nature," abdita et caligine
involuta naturz,—he reading of all edd. except Hild. and Oehler, who
follow the Ms. abditz cal.—'* enwrapt in darkness of hidden nature."
* This has been supposed to refer to Heraclitus, as quoted by Clem.
Alex. Stromata, v. p. 599 B., where his words are, ‘‘ Neither God nor
man made the world; but there was always, and is, and will be, an
undying flame laying hold of its limits, and destroying them ;" on which
cf. p. 73, n. 1. Here, of course, fire does not mean that perceived by
the senses, but a subtle, all-penetrating energy.
5 Of. ch. 52, n. 2, p. 120.
96 Lit., '' by ordinary necessity." The Stoics (Diog. Laert. vii. 134)
said that the world was made by God working on uncreated matter, and
that it was perishable (8 141), because made through that of which
perception could take cognizance. Cf. ch. 31, n. 7, p. 98.
* Orelli thinks that there is here a confusion of the parts of the world
with its elements, because he can nowhere find that any philosopher
has fixed the number of the elements either above or below four. The
Stoies, however (Diog. Laert. vii. 134), said “ that the elements (dpx«s)