no longer doubtful to reflecting persons that this poisonous dose of argument, of which a
specimen has been shown in what we have already examined, will continue throughout to
be such as that which we have just refuted. For this reason I think it better not to prolong
307
this detailed dwelling upon his absurdities. Nevertheless, seeing that the champions of this
error discover plausibility for it from many quarters, and there is reason to fear lest to have
overlooked any of their efforts will be made a specious pretext for misrepresenting us as
having shirked their strongest point, I beg for this reason those who follow us out in this
work to accompany our argument still, without charging us with prolixity, while it expands
itself to meet the attacks of error along the whole line. Observe, then, that he has scarcely
ceased weaving in the depths of his slumber this dream about conception before he arms
himself again from his storehouse with those monstrous and senseless methods, and turns
his argument into another dream much more meaningless than his previous illusion. But
we may best know how absurd his efforts are by observing his treatment of “privation”;
though to grapple with his nonsense in all its range would require a Eunomius, or one of
his school, men who have never spent a thought on serious realities. We will, however, in
a concise way run over the heads of it, that while none of his charges is omitted, no mean-
ingless item may help to prolong the discussion to an absurd length.
When, then, he is on the point of introducing this treatment of terms of “privation,” he
takes upon himself to show “the incurable absurdity,” as he calls it, of our teaching, and its
“simulated and culpable caution1200.” Such is his promise; but the proof of these accusations
is, what? “Some have said that the Deity is ungenerate by virtue only of the privation of
generation; but we say, in refutation of these, that neither this word nor this idea is in any
way whatever applicable to the Deity.” Let him point out the maintainer of such a statement,
if any from the first creation of man to the present day, whether in foreign or in Greek lands,
has ever committed himself to such an utterance; and we will be silent. But no one in the
whole history of mankind will be found to have said such a thing, except some madman.
For who was ever so reeling from intoxication, who was ever so beside himself with madness
or delirium, as to say, in so many words, that generation belongs naturally to the ungenerate
God, but that, deprived of this natural condition, He becomes ungenerate instead of gener-
ated? But these are the shifts of rhetoric; namely, to escape when they are refuted from the
shame of their refutation by means of some supposititious characters. It was in this way that
he has apologized for that celebrated “Apology” of his, transferring as he did the blame for
that title to jurymen and accusers1201, though unable to show that there were any accusers,
any trial, or any court at all. Now, too, with the air of one who would correct another’s folly,
he pretends that he is driven by necessity to speak in this way. This is what his proof of our
1200 εὐλαβείαν τινὰ προσποίητον καὶ ἐπίληπτον
1201 See Book I. vii., ix., xi.
574
Answer to Eunomius' Second Book.