Rev. ii. 6,
15.
Salmon, in his article Nicolaitans, in the Dict. of Christ.
Biog., states, as I think, quite correctly, that “there
really is no trustworthy evidence of the continuance of a sect so
called after the death of the apostle John”; and in this he is in
agreement with many modern scholars. An examination of extant accounts
of this sect seems to show that nothing more was known of the
Nicolaitans by any of the Fathers than what is told in the Apocalypse.
Justin, whose lost work against heretics Irenæus follows in his
description of heresies, seems to have made no mention of the
Nicolaitans, for they are dragged in by Irenæus at the close of
the text, quite out of their chronological place. Irenæus (I. 26.
3; III. 11. 1) seems to have made up his account from the Apocalypse,
and to have been the sole source for later writers upon this subject.
That the sect was licentious is told us by the Apocalypse. That
Nicolas, one of the Seven, was their founder is stated by Irenæus
(I. 26. 3), Hippolytus (VII. 24), Pseudo-Tertullian (Adv. omnes
Hær. chap. 1), and Epiphanius (Hær. 25), the last
two undoubtedly drawing their account from Hippolytus, and he in turn
from Irenæus. Jerome and the writers of his time and later accept
this view, believing that Nicolas became licentious and fell into the
greatest wickedness. Whether the sect really claimed Nicolas as their
founder, or whether the combination was made by Irenæus in
consequence of the identity of his name with the name of a sect
mentioned in the Apocalypse, we cannot tell; nor have we any idea, in
the latter case, where the sect got the name which they bore. Clement
of Alexandria, in the passage quoted just below, gives us quite a
different account of the character of Nicolas; and as he is a more
reliable writer than the ones above quoted, and as his statement
explains excellently the appeal of the sect to Nicolas’
authority, without impeaching his character, which certainly his
position among the Seven would lead us to expect was good, and good
enough to warrant permanence, we feel safe in accepting his account as
the true one, and denying that Nicolas himself bore the character which
marked the sect of the Nicolaitans; though the latter may, as Clement
says, have arisen from abusing a saying of Nicolas which had been
uttered with a good motive.