It may be well to add a few words upon the
supposed Coptic acts of this council, and upon their connection with
the very ancient Syntagma Doctrinæ, wrongly so named, and
wrongly ascribed to Athanasius. These ‘acts’ are in reality
a series of documents consisting of (1) The Nicene Creed, Canons, and
Signatures; (2) A Coptic recension of the Syntagma
Doctrinæ; (3) the letter of Paulinus from Tom. Ant.,
sub fin., a letter of Epiphanius, and a fragmentary letter of
‘Rufinus,’ i.e. Rufinianus (see infr. p. 566, note
1). Revillout, who published these texts from a Turin and a Roman
(Borgia) manuscript in 1881 (Le Concile de Nicée d’apres
les textes Coptes) jumped (Archives des missions scientifiques
et littéraires, 1879) at the conclusion that the whole series
emanated from the council of 362, from whose labours all our copies of
the Nicene canons and signatures are supposed by him to emanate. His
theory cannot be discussed at length in this place. It is worked out
with ingenuity, but with insufficient knowledge of general Church
history. It appears to be adopted wholesale by Eichhorn in his
otherwise critical and excellent Athanasii de vita ascetica
testimonia (see below, p. 189); but even those whose scepticism has
not been awaked by the hypothesis itself must I think be satisfied by
the careful study of M. Batiffol (Studia Patristica, fasc. ii.)
that Revillout has erected a castle in the air. Of any
‘acts’ of the Council of 362 the documents contain no trace
at all. It is therefore out of place to do more than allude here to the
great interest of the Syntagma in its three or four extant
recensions in connection at once with the history of Egyptian
Monasticism and with the literature of the Διδαχὴ τῶν
ιβ'
ἀποστόλων (see
Harnack in Theol. Litzg. 1887, pp. 32, sqq., Eichhorn,
ib. p. 569, Warfield in Andover Review, 1886, p. 81,
sqq., and other American literature referred to by Harnack
a.a.O).