But to persist in such teaching does not consist
with piety i.e.
since it is impossible they can persist in evasions so manifest as
these, nothing is left but to take the other sense of the
word., for it is rather the tone of thought
of Sadducees and the Samosatene Paul of
Samosata [see Prolegg. ch. ii. §3 (2)a.]; it remains then to
say that the Son of God is so called according to the other sense, in
which Isaac was son of Abraham; for what is naturally begotten from any
one and does not accrue to him from without, that in the nature of
things is a son, and that is what the name implies The
force lies in the word φύσει,
‘naturally,’ which the Council expressed still more
definitely by ‘essence.’ Thus Cyril says, ‘the term
“Son” denotes the essential origin from the Father.’
Dial. 5. p. 573. And Gregory Nyssen, ‘the title
“Son” does not simply express the being from
another’ vid. infra. §19.), but relationship according to
nature. contr. Eunom. ii. p. 91. Again S. Basil says, that Father
is ‘a term of relationship,’ οἰκειώσεως. contr. Eunom. ii. 24. init. And hence he remarks,
that we too are properly, κυρίως,
sons of God, as becoming related to Him through works of the Spirit.
ii. 23. So also Cyril, loc. cit. Elsewhere S. Basil defines
father ‘one who gives to another the origin of being according to
a nature like his own;’ and a son ‘one who possesses the
origin of being from another by generation,’ contr. Eun.
ii. 22. On the other hand, the Arians at the first denied that
‘by nature there was any Son of God.’ Theod. H. E.
i. 3. p. 732..
Is then the Son’s generation one of human affection? (for this
perhaps, as their predecessors vid.
Eusebius, in his Letter, supr. p. 73 sq.: also Socr.
Hist. i. 8. Epiphan. Hær. 69. n. 8 and
15., they too will be
ready to object in their ignorance;)—in no wise; for God is not
as man, nor men as God. Men were created of matter, and that passible;
but God is immaterial and incorporeal. And if so be the same terms are
used of God and man in divine Scripture, yet the clear-sighted, as Paul
enjoins, will study it, and thereby discriminate, and dispose of what
is written according to the nature of each subject, and avoid any
confusion of sense, so as neither to conceive of the things of God in a
human way, nor to ascribe the things of man to God One of
the characteristic points in Athanasius is his constant attention to
the sense of doctrine, or the meaning of writers, in
preference to the words used. Thus he scarcely uses the symbol
ὁμοούσιον, one in substance, throughout his Orations, and in
the de Synod. acknowledges the Semiarians as brethren. Hence
infr. §18. he says, that orthodox doctrine ‘is revered by
all though expressed in strange language, provided the speaker means
religiously, and wishes to convey by it a religious sense.’ vid.
also §21. He says, that Catholics are able to ‘speak
freely,’ or to expatiate, παρρησιαζόμεθα, ‘out of Divine Scripture.’ Orat. i.
§9. vid. de Sent. Dionys. §20. init. Again: ‘The
devil spoke from Scripture, but was silenced by the Saviour; Paul spoke
from profane writers, yet, being a saint, he has a religious
meaning.’ de Syn. §39, also ad Ep. Æg. 8.
Again, speaking of the apparent contrariety between two Councils,
‘It were unseemly to make the one conflict with the other, for
all their members are fathers; and it were profane to decide that these
spoke well and those ill, for all of them have slept in Christ.’
§43. also §47. Again: ‘Not the phrase, but the meaning
and the religious life, is the recommendation of the faithful.’
ad Ep. Æg. §9..
For this were to mix wine with
water vid.
Orat. iii. §35, and Isa. i. 22., and to place upon the altar strange fire
with that which is divine.