We now turn to the Apostles. Here a few brief
remarks must suffice. (A suggestive summary in Sanday, ‘What the
first Christians thought about Christ,’ Oxford House Papers,
First Series.) That S. Paul’s summary of the Gospel (1 Cor. xv. 3 sqq.) is given by him as common
ground between himself and the older Apostles follows strictly from the
fact that the verb used (παρέλαβον)
links the facts of Redemption (v. 3, 4) with the personal experiences of the
original disciples (5
sqq.). In fact it is not in dispute that the original Jewish
nucleus of the Apostolic Church preached Jesus as the Messiah, and His
death as the ground of forgiveness of sins (Pfleiderer,
Urchrist. p. 20; Acts
ii. 36, 38; iii. 26; iv. 12,
&c.; the ‘Hebraic colouring’ of these early chapters is
very characteristic and important). The question is, however, how much
this implied as to the Divine Personality of the Saviour; how far the
belief of the Apostles and their contemporaries was uniform and
explicit on this point. Important light is thrown on this question by
the controversy which divided S. Paul from the mass of Jewish
Christians with respect to the observance of the Law. Our primary
source of knowledge here is Galatians, ch. ii. We there learn that while S. Paul
regarded this question as involving the whole essence of the Gospel,
and resisted every attempt to impose circumcision on Gentile
Christians, the older Apostles conceded the one point regarded as
central, and, while reserving the obligation of the Law on those born
under it (which S. Paul never directly assailed, 1 Cor. vii. 18) recognised the Gospel of the
uncircumcision as legitimate. This concession, as the event proved,
conceded everything; if the ‘gospel of the uncircumcision’
was sufficient for salvation, circumcision became a national, not a
religious principle. Now this whole question was fundamentally a
question about Christ. Men who believed, or were willing to grant, that
the Law uttered from Sinai by the awful voice of the Most High Himself
was no longer the supreme revelation of God, the one divinely ordained
covenant of righteousness, certainly believed that some revelation of
God different in kind (for no revelation of God to man
could surpass the degree of Ex. xxxiii. 11) had taken place, an unique revelation
of God in man. The revelation of God in Christ, not the
revelation of God to Moses, was the one fact in the world’s
history; Sinai was dwarfed in comparison of Calvary. But it must be
observed that while the older Apostles, by the very recognition of the
gospel of the uncircumcision, went thus far with S. Paul, S. Paul
realised as a central principle what to others lay at the
circumference. What to the one was a result of their belief in
Christ was to him the starting-point, from which logical conclusions
were seen to follow, practical applications made in every direction. At
the same time S. Paul taught nothing about Christ that was not
implied in the belief of the older Apostles, or that they would
not have felt impelled by their own religious position to accept. In
fact it was their fundamental union in the implicit belief of the
divinity of the Lord that made possible any agreement between S. Paul
and the Jewish Apostles as to the gospel of the uncircumcision.