Silvanus on the contrary pointed
out that it was their duty to reject and expel from their holy
assemblies the phrases “out of the non-existent” and
“creature” and “of another
substance,” these terms being also unscriptural and found in
the writings of neither prophets nor apostles. Constantius decided that
this was right, and bade the Arians pronounce the condemnation. At
first they persisted in refusing; but in the end, when they saw the
emperor’s wrath, they consented, though much against the grain,
to condemn the terms Silvanus had put before them. But all the more
earnestly they insisted on their demand for the condemnation of the
“Homoüsion.” But then with unanswerable logic
Silvanus put both before the Arians and the emperor the truth that if
God the Word is not of the non-Existent, He is not a Creature, and is
not of another Substance. He is then of one Substance with God Who begat Him,
as God of God and Light of Light, and has the same nature as the
Begetter. This contention he urged with power and with truth, but not
one of his hearers was convinced. The party of Acacius and Eudoxius
raised a mighty uproar; the emperor was angered, and threatened
expulsion from their churches. Thereupon Eleusius and Silvanus and the
rest said that while authority to punish lay with the emperor, it was
their province to decide on points of piety or impiety, and “we
will not,” they protested, “betray the doctrine of the
Fathers.”