493
earthly body? What does this soul, which is finer than all else, do in such a mass of matter
as this? What does the lightest of substances do in this ponderosity? this swiftest substance
in such sluggishness? Will not the body be raised to heaven by virtue of so excellent a nature
as this? and if now earthly bodies can retain the souls below, shall not the souls be one day
able to raise the earthly bodies above?
If we pass now to their miracles which they oppose to our martyrs as wrought by their
gods, shall not even these be found to make for us, and help out our argument? For if any
of the miracles of their gods are great, certainly that is a great one which Varro mentions
of a vestal virgin, who, when she was endangered by a false accusation of unchastity, filled
a sieve with water from the Tiber, and carried it to her judges without any part of it leaking.
Who kept the weight of water in the sieve? Who prevented any drop from falling from it
through so many open holes? They will answer, Some god or some demon. If a god, is he
greater than the God who made the world? If a demon, is he mightier than an angel who
serves the God by whom the world was made? If, then, a lesser god, angel, or demon could
so sustain the weight of this liquid element that the water might seem to have changed its
nature, shall not Almighty God, who Himself created all the elements, be able to eliminate
from the earthly body its heaviness, so that the quickened body shall dwell in whatever ele-
ment the quickening spirit pleases?
Then, again, since they give the air a middle place between the fire above and the water
beneath, how is it that we often find it between water and water, and between the water and
the earth? For what do they make of those watery clouds, between which and the seas air
is constantly found intervening? I should like to know by what weight and order of the
elements it comes to pass that very violent and stormy torrents are suspended in the clouds
above the earth before they rush along upon the earth under the air. In fine, why is it that
throughout the whole globe the air is between the highest heaven and the earth, if its place
is between the sky and the water, as the place of the water is between the sky and the earth?
Finally, if the order of the elements is so disposed that, as Plato thinks, the two extremes,
fire and earth, are united by the two means, air and water, and that the fire occupies the
highest part of the sky, and the earth the lowest part, or as it were the foundation of the
world, and that therefore earth cannot be in the heavens, how is fire in the earth? For, ac-
cording to this reasoning, these two elements, earth and fire, ought to be so restricted to
their own places, the highest and the lowest, that neither the lowest can rise to the place of
the highest, nor the highest sink to that of the lowest. Thus, as they think that no particle
of earth is or shall ever be in the sky so we ought to see no particle of fire on the earth. But
the fact is that it exists to such an extent, not only on but even under the earth, that the tops
of mountains vomit it forth; besides that we see it to exist on earth for human uses, and even
to be produced from the earth, since it is kindled from wood and stones, which are without
doubt earthly bodies. But that [upper] fire, they say, is tranquil, pure, harmless, eternal; but
1103
Against the Platonists, Who Argue from the Physical Weight of the Elements…