The above are the principal materials for a
decision as to the genuineness of the Vita: and I do not see how
they can justify any opinion but that stated at the outset. Against the
Vita we have certain historical difficulties (intercourse with
Athanasius, peregrini fratres, Balacius), and arguments ex
silentio, a kind of evidence seldom conclusive. For it, we have a
quite unusual array of external evidence, including an almost
contemporary version, the absence of any room for its date at a safe
distance from its traditional author, and the many points of contact,
as well as the characteristic differences between the Vita and
the writings of Athanasius. Moreover on the kindred question of the
origin of monasticism, Weingarten’s theory breaks down, and leads him to suicidal
steps in more than one direction. Although, therefore, it is
permissible to keep an open mind on the subject, we must recognise that
the enterprise of the recent assailants of the Vita is at
present at a dead halt, that overwhelming probability is against
them.