Introductory Notice
to
The Decretals.
————————————
The
learned editors of the
Edinburgh series have given us only a specimen of these frauds, which,
pretending to be a series of “papal edicts” from Clement
and his successors during the
ante-Nicene ages
, are, in fact,
the manufactured product of the
ninth century
,—the most
stupendous imposture of the world’s history, the most successful
and the most stubborn in its hold upon enlightened nations. Like
the mason’s framework of lath and scantlings, on which he turns
an arch of massive stone, the Decretals served their purpose, enabling
Nicholas I. to found the Papacy by their insignificant aid. That
swelling arch of vanity once reared, the framework might be knocked
out; but the fabric stood, and has borne up every weight imposed upon
it for ages. Its strong abutments have been ignorance and
despotism. Nicholas produced his flimsy framework of imposture,
and amazed the whole Church by the audacity of the claims he founded
upon it. The age, however, was unlearned and uncritical; and, in
spite of remonstrances from France under lead of Hincmar, bishop of
Rheims, the West patiently submitted to the overthrow of the ancient
Canons and the Nicene Constitutions, and bowed to the yoke of a new
canon-law, of which these frauds were not only made an integral, but
the essential, part. The East never accepted them for a
moment: her great patriarchates retain the Nicene System to this
day. But, as the established religion of the “Holy Roman
Empire,” the national churches of Western Europe, one by one,
succumbed to this revolt from historic Catholicity. The Eastern
churches were the more numerous. They stood by the Constitutions
confirmed by all the Œcumenical Synods; they altered not a word of
the Nicene Creed; they stood up for the great Catholic law, “Let
the ancient customs prevail;” and they were, and are to this day,
the grand historic stem of Christendom
. The Papacy created
the Western schism, and contrived to call it “the schism of the
Greeks.” The Decretals had created the Papacy, and they
enabled the first Pope to assume that communion with himself was the
test of Catholic communion: hence his excommunication of the
Easterns, which, after brief intervals of relaxation, settled into the
chronic schism of the Papacy, and produced the awful history of the
mediæval Church in Western Europe.
In naming Nicholas I. as the founder of the
Papacy, and the first Pope, I merely reach the logical consequence of
admitted facts and demonstrated truths. I merely apply the
recognised principles of modern thought and scientific law to the
science of history, and dismiss the technology of empiricism in this
science, as our age has abolished similar empiricisms in the exact
sciences. For ages after Copernicus, even those who basked in the
light of the true system of the universe went on in the old ruts,
talking
as if the Ptolemaic theory were yet a reality: and
so the very historians whose lucid pages explode the whole fabric of
the Papal communion, still go on, in the language of fable, giving to
the early Bishops of Rome the title of “Popes;” counting
St. Peter as the first Pope; bewildering the student by many confusions
of fact with fable; and conceding to the modern fabric of Romanism the
name of “the Catholic Church,” with all the immense
advantages that accrue to falsehood by such a surrender of truth, and
the consequent endowment of imposture with the raiment and the domain
of Apostolic antiquity.
The student of this
series must have noted the following fundamental facts:—
1. That the name
papa
was common to
all bishops, and signified no pre-eminence in those who bore
it.
2. That the Apostolic Sees were all equally
accounted
matrices
of unity, and the
roots
of other
Catholic churches.
3. That, down to the Council of Nicæa, the
whole system of the Church was framed on this principle, and that these
were the “ancient customs” which that council ordained to
be perpetual.
4. That “because it was the old
capital of the empire,” and
for no other reason
(the
Petrine idea never once mentioned), the primacy of
honour
was
conceded to Old Rome, and
equal
honour to New Rome, because it
was the new capital.
2681
It was
to be named second on the list of patriarchates, but to be in no wise
inferior to Old Rome; while the ancient and all-commanding patriarchate
of Alexandria yielded this credit to the
parvenu
of
Byzantium only on the principle of the Gospel, “in honour
preferring one another,” and only because the imperial capital
must be the centre of Catholic concourse.
Now, the rest of the story must be sought in post-Nicene
history. The salient points are as follows:—
1. The mighty centralization about Constantinople;
the three councils held within its walls; the virtual session of the
other councils under its eaves; the inconsiderable figure of “Old
Rome” in strictly ecclesiastical history; her barrenness of
literature, and of great heroic sons, like Athanasius and Chrysostom in
the East, and Cyprian and Augustine in the West; and her decadence as a
capital,—had led Leo I., and others after him, to dwell much upon
“St. Peter,” and to favour new ideas of his personal
greatness, and of a transmitted grandeur as the inheritance of his
successors. As yet, these were but “great swelling words of
vanity;” but they led to the formulated fraud of the
Decretals.
2. Ambition once entering the pale of Catholicity,
we find a counter idea to that of the councils at the root of the first
usurpation of unscriptural dignity. John “the
Faster,” bishop of New Rome, conceived himself not merely equal
(as the councils had decreed) to the bishop of Old Rome, but his
superior, in view of the decrepitude of the latter, and its occupation
by the Goths, while the imperial dignity of Constantinople was now
matured. He called himself “Œcumenical
Bishop.”
3. Gregory was then bishop of “Old
Rome,” and that was the time to assert the principle of the
Decretals, had any such idea ever been heard of. How did he meet
his brother’s arrogance? Not appealing to decretals, not by
asserting that such was his own dignity derived from St. Peter, but by
protesting against such abasement of all the other patriarchs and all
other bishops (who were all equals), and by pronouncing the impious
assumption of such a nefarious title to denote a “forerunner of
Antichrist.” Plainly, then, there was no “Pope”
known to Christendom at the close of the sixth century.
4. But hardly was Gregory in his grave when
court policy led the Emperor Phocas (one of the most infamous of men)
to gratify the wicked ambition of the new Bishop of Rome by giving to
him the titular honour of being a “forerunner of
Antichrist.” Boniface III. (607
a.d.
) assumed the daring title of “Universal
Bishop.” But it was a mere court-title: the Church
never recognised it; and so it went down to his successors as mere
“sounding brass and a tinkling cymbal” till the days of
Charlemagne.
5. In his times the Petrine fable had grown
upon the Western mind. All Western Europe had but one Apostolic
See. As “
the
Apostolic See” it was known
throughout the West, just as “
the
Post-Office” means
that which is nearest to one’s own dwelling. What was
geographically true, had grown to be theologically false, however; and
the Bishop of Rome began to consider himself the only inheritor of
Apostolic precedency, if not of all Apostolic authority and
power.
6. The
formation of the Western Empire favoured this assumption: but it
did not take definite shape while Charlemagne lived, for he regarded
himself, like Constantine, the “head of the
Church;”
2682
and in his
day he acted as supreme pontiff, called the Council of Frankfort,
overruled the Roman bishop, and, in short, was a lay-Pope throughout
his empire. That nobody refused him all he claimed, that Adrian
“couched like a strong ass” under the burden of his
rebukes, and that Leo paid him bodily “homage,”
demonstrated that no such character as a “Pope” was yet in
existence. Leo III. had personally “adored”
Charlemagne with the homage afterwards rendered to the pontiffs, and
Adrian had set him the example of personal submission.
7. But, Charlemagne’s feeble sons and
successors proving incapable of exercising his power, the West only
waited for an ambitious and original genius to come to the See of Rome,
to yield him all that Charlemagne had claimed, and to invest him with
the more sacred character of the Apostolic head to the whole
Church.
8. Such a character arose in Nicholas
I. He found the Decretals made to his hand by some impostor, and
he saw a benighted age ready to accept his assumptions. He
therefore used them, and passed them into the organic canon-law of the
West. The “Holy Roman Empire” reluctantly received
the impious frauds
2683
the East
contemptuously resisted. Thus the Papacy was formed on the base
of the “Holy Roman Empire,” and arrogated to itself the
right to cut off and anathematize the greater part of Christendom, with
the old patriarchal Sees. So we have in Nicholas the first figure
in history in whose person is concentrated what Rome means by the
Papacy. No “Pope” ever existed previously, in the
sense of her canon-law; and it was not till two centuries longer that
even a “Pope” presumed to pronounce that title
peculiar
to the Bishop of Rome.
2684
Such, then, are the historical facts, which render
vastly important some study of the Decretals. I shall give what
follows exclusively from “Roman-Catholic” sources.
Says the learned Dupin:
2685
—
1. All these
Decretals
were unknown
to all the ancient Fathers, to all the Popes and all the ecclesiastical
authors
that wrote before the ninth century
. Now, what
rational man can believe that so vast a number of letters, composed by
so many holy Popes, containing so many important points in relation to
the discipline of the Church, could be unknown to Eusebius, to St.
Jerome, to St. Augustine, to St. Basil, and, in short, to all those
authors that have spoken of their writings, or who have written upon
the discipline of the Church? Could it possibly happen that the
Popes, to whom these epistles are so very favourable, would never have
cited and alleged them to aggrandize their own reputation? Who
could ever imagine that the decisions of these Decretals
should be
never so much as quoted
in any council or in any canon? He
that will seriously consider with himself, that, since these Decretals
have been imposed upon the world,
they have been cited in an
infinite number of places by Popes, by councils, and as often by
canonists
, will be readily convinced that they would have acquired
immense credit, and been very often quoted by antiquity, if they had
been genuine and true.
Here I must direct attention to the all-important
fact, that whatever may have been the authorship of these forgeries,
the Roman pontiffs, and the “Roman Catholic” communion as
such, have committed themselves over and over again to the fraud, as
Dupin remarks above, and that, long after the imposture was
demonstrated and exposed; in proof of which I cite the following, from
one whose eyes were opened by his patient investigation of such facts,
but who, while a member of the Roman communion, wrote to his
co-religionist Cardinal Manning as follows:
2686
—
Is it credible that the Papacy should have so
often appealed to these forgeries for its extended claims, had it any
better authorities—
distinctive
authorities—to fall
back upon? Every disputant on the Latin side finds in these
forgeries a convincing argument against the Greeks. ‘To
prove this,’ the universal jurisdiction of the Pope, said Abbot
Barlaam, himself converted by them from the Greek Church, to convert
his countrymen, ‘one need only look through the decretal epistles
of the Roman pontiffs from St. Clement to St. Sylvester.’
In the
twenty-fifth
session of the Council of Florence the provincial of the Dominicans is
ordered to address the Greeks on the rights of the Pope, the Pope being
present. Twice he argues from the pseudo-decretal of St.
Anacletus, at another time from a synodical letter of St. Athanasius to
Felix, at another time from a letter of Julius to the Easterns,
all
forgeries
. Afterwards, in reply to objections taken by
Bessarion, in conference, to their authority, apart from any question
of their authenticity, his position in another speech is, ‘that
those decretal epistles of the Popes
, being synodical epistles
in each case, are entitled to the same authority as the Canons
themselves.’ Can we need further evidence of the weight
attached to them on the Latin side?
“Popes appealed to them in their official
capacity, as well as private doctors; (1) Leo IX., for instance, to the
pseudo-donation in the prolix epistle written by him, or in his name,
to Michael Cerularius, patriarch of Constantinople, on the eve of the
schism. (2) Eugenius IV. to the pseudo-decretals of St. Alexander
and Julius, during the negotiations for healing it, in his instructions
to the Armenians. (3) But why, my lord, need I travel any further
for proofs, when in the Catechism of the Council of Trent, that has
been for three centuries
the accredited instructor of the clergy
themselves, recommended authoritatively by so many Popes,
notwithstanding the real value of these miserable impostures
had
been for three centuries before the world, I find these words:
2687
‘On the primacy of the
Supreme Pontiff, see the third epistle (that is, pseudo-decretal) of
Anacletus’! Such is, actually, the authority to which the
clergy of our own days are referred,
in the first instance
, for
sound and true views on the primacy. (4) Afterwards, when they
have mastered what is said there, they may turn to three more
authorities, all culled likewise from Gratian, which they will not fail
to interpret in accordance with the ideas they have already
imbibed. Nor can I refrain from calling attention to a much more
flagrant case. On the sacrament of confirmation there had been
many questions raised by the Reformers, calculated to set people
thinking, and anxious to know the strict truth respecting it. On
this the Catechism proceeds as follows:
2688
—
“‘Since it has been already shown how
necessary it would be to teach generally respecting all the sacraments,
by whom they were instituted, so there is need of similar instruction
respecting confirmation, that the faithful may be the more attracted by
the holiness of this sacrament.
Pastors must therefore
explain
that not only was Christ our Lord the author of it, but
that, on the authority of the Roman pontiff St. Fabian (i.e., the
pseudo-decretal attributed to him), He instituted the rite of the
chrism, and the words used by the Catholic Church in its
administration.’
“Strange phenomenon, indeed, that the
asseverations of such authorities should be still
ordered to be
taught as Gospel
from our pulpits in these days, when everybody
that is acquainted with the merest rudiments of ecclesiastical history
knows how absolutely unauthenticated they are in point of fact, and how
unquestionably the authorities cited to prove them are
forgeries.
“Absolutely, my lord, with such evidence
before me, I am unable to resist the inference that
truthfulness
is not one of the strongest characteristics of the teaching of even the
modern Church of Rome; for is not this a case palpably where its
highest living authorities are both indifferent to having possible
untruths preached from the pulpit, and something more than indifferent
to having forgeries, after their detection as such, adduced from the
pulpit to authenticate facts?
“This, again, strongly reminds me of a
conversation I had with the excellent French priest who received me
into the Roman-Catholic Church, some time subsequently to that
event. I had, as an Anglican, inquired very laboriously into the
genuineness of the
Santa Casa
: and having visited Nazareth
and Loretto since, and plunged into the question anew at each place,
came back more thoroughly convinced than ever of its utterly fictitious
character, notwithstanding the privileges bestowed upon it by so many
Popes. On stating my convictions to him, his only reply
was: ‘There are many things in the Breviary which I do not
believe, myself.’ Oh the stumbling-blocks of a system in
the construction of which forgeries have been so largely used, in which
it is still thought possible for the clergy to derive edification from
legends which they cannot believe, and the people instruction from
works of acknowledged imposture!
Further, Dupin remarks:
2689
—
“The first man that published them, if we may
believe Hincmar, was one Riculphus, bishop of Mentz, who died about the
ninth century. It is commonly believed, seeing the collection
bears the name of Isidore, that he brought them from Spain. But
it never could have been composed by the great Archbishop of Seville;
and there is great reason to believe that no Spaniard, but rather some
German or Frenchman, began this imposture,
“It likewise seems probable that some of these
Decretals have been foisted in since the time of Riculphus.
Benedict, a deacon of the church of Mentz, who made a collection of
canons for the successors of Riculphus, may have put the last hand to
this collection of false Decretals attributed to one Isidore, a
different person from the famous Bishop of Seville, and surnamed
Peccator, or Mercator. About his time a certain Isidore did come
from Spain, along with some merchants, and then withdrew to
Mentz. Not improbably, therefore, this man’s name was given
to the collection, and it was naturally believed that it was brought
from Spain.
“And since these letters first appeared in an
unlearned, dark age, what wonder is it that they were received
with very little opposition?
And yet Archbishop Hincmar of Rheims, with other French bishops, made
great difficulty in accepting them, even in that time. Soon
after, however, they acquired some authority, owing to the support of
the court of Rome, the pretensions of which they mightily favoured.
On the twin imposture of the “Donation of
Constantine,” it may be well to cite the same learned
authority. But this shall be found elsewhere.
2690
Let me now recur to the same candid Gallican doctor,
Dupin, who remarks as follows:—
“2. The imposture of these letters is
invincibly proved from hence: because they are made up of a
contexture
of passages out of Fathers, councils, papal epistles,
and imperial ordinances, which have appeared after the third century,
down to the middle of the ninth
.
“3. The citations of Scripture in all
these letters
follow the Vulgate
of St. Jerome, which
demonstrates that they are since his time (
a.d.
420), and consequently do not proceed from Popes who lived long before
St. Jerome.
“4. The matter of these letters is not at
all in keeping with the ages when those to whom they are attributed
were living.
“5. These
Decretals
are full of
anachronisms. The consulships and names of consuls mentioned in
them are confused and out of order; and, moreover, the true dates of
the writers themselves, as Bishops of Rome, do not agree with those
assumed in these letters.
“6. Their style is extremely
barbarous, full of solecisms; and in them we often meet with certain
words
never used till the later ages
. Also, they are all
of one style! How does it happen that so many different Popes,
living in divers centuries, should all write in the same
manner?”
Dupin then goes on to examine the whole series
with learning and candour, showing that
every single one of them
“carries with it unequivocal signs of lying and
imposture.” To his pages let the student recur,
therefore. I follow him in the following enumeration of the
frauds he calmly exposes with searching logic and
demonstration:—
1.
St. Clement to St. James the
Lord’s Brother
.—Plainly spurious.
2.
The Second Epistle of Clement to the
Same
.—Equally so.
3.
St. Clement to all Suffragan Bishops,
Priests, Deacons, and Others of the Clergy: to all Princes Great
and Small, and to all the Faithful.
Dupin remarks: “This very title
suffices to prove the forgery, as, in the days of St. Clement, there
were no “princes great or small” in the
Church.” He adds that it speaks of
“subdeacons,” an order not then existing, and that it is
patched up from scraps of the apocryphal
Recognitions
.
4.
A Fourth Letter of the Same
.
It is self-refuted by “the same reasons.”
5.
The Fifth Letter to St. James of St.
Clement, Bishop of Rome and Successor of St. Peter
.
“But,” says Dupin, “as St. James died
before St. Peter, it necessarily follows, that this epistle cannot have
been written by St. Clement.” Further, “We have one
genuine epistle of St. Clement, the style of which is wholly different
from that of these Decretals.”
6.
The Epistle of
Anacletus
.—Barbarous, full of solecisms and
falsehoods.
7.
A Second Epistle of
Anacletus
.—Filled with passages out of authors who lived long
after the times of Anacletus.
8.
A Third Letter,
etc.
.—Spurious for the same reasons.
9.
An Epistle of
Evaristus
.—Patched up out of writings of Innocent in the
fifth century, dated under consuls not contemporaries of the alleged
writer.
10.
A Second Epistle of the
Same
.—Stuffed with patchwork of later centuries.
11.
An Epistle of
Alexander
.—Contains passages from at least one author of the
eighth century.
12.
A Second Epistle of the
Same
.—Refers to the Council of Laodicea, which was held
(
a.d.
365) after Alexander was dead.
13.
A Third Epistle,
etc
.—Quotes an author of the fifth century.
14.
An Epistle of Xystus
.—Dated
under a consul that lived in another age, and quotes authors of
centuries later than his own day.
15.
A Second Epistle of the
Same
.—Subject to the same objections, anachronisms,
etc.
16.
An Epistle of Telesphorus
.—False dates, patched from
subsequent authors, etc.
17.
An Epistle of
Hyginus
.—Anachronisms, etc.
18.
A Second of the
Same
.—Stuffed with anachronisms, and falsely dated by consuls
not of his age.
19.
An Epistle of Pius I
.—Full
of absurdities, and quotes “the Theodosian
Code”!
20.
A Second
.—It is addressed
to Justus, etc. Bad Latin, and wholly unknown to antiquity,
though Baronius has tried to sustain it.
21.
A Third Letter,
etc
.—Addressed to Justus, bishop of Vienna. False for
the same reasons.
22.
An Epistle of
Anicetus
.—Full of blunders as to dates, etc. Mentions
names, titles, and the like, unheard of till later ages.
23.
An Epistle of Soter
.—Dated
under consuls who lived before Soter was bishop of Rome.
24.
A Second Letter,
etc
.—Speaks of “monks,” “palls,” and
other things of later times; is patched out of writings of subsequent
ages, and dated under consuls not his contemporaries.
25.
An Epistle of
Eleutherus
.—Subject to like objections.
26.
A Second Letter,
etc
.—Anachronisms.
27.
A Third Letter,
etc
.—Addressed to “Desiderius, bishop of
Vienna.” There was no such bishop till the sixth
century.
28.
A Fourth Letter,
etc
.—Quotes later authors, and is disproved by its
style.
29.
An Epistle of
Zephyrinus
.—Little importance to be attached to anything from
such a source; but Dupin (who lived before his bad character came to
light in the writings of Hippolytus) convicts it of ignorance, and
shows that it is a patchwork of later ideas and writers.
30.
A Second Letter
.—“Yet
more plainly an imposture,” says Dupin.
31.
An Epistle of St.
Callistus
.—What sort of a “saint” he was, our
readers are already informed. This epistle is like the preceding
ones of Zephyrinus.
32.
A Second Epistle,
etc
.—Quotes from writings of the eighth century.
33.
An Epistle of Urban
.—Quotes
the Vulgate, the Theodosian Code, and Gregory the Fourth.
34.
An Epistle of
Pontianus
.—Anachronisms.
35.
A Second Epistle,
etc
.—Barbarous and impossible.
36.
An Epistle of
Anterus
.—Equally impossible; stuffed with
anachronisms.
37.
An Epistle of
Fabianus
.—Contradicts the facts of history touching Cyprian,
Cornelius, and Novatus.
38.
A Second Epistle,
etc
.—Self-refuted by its monstrous details of mistake and the
like.
39.
A Third Epistle,
etc
.—Quotes authors of the sixth century.
40.
An Epistle of
Cornelius
.—Contradicts historical facts, etc.
41.
A Second Epistle,
etc
.—Equally full of blunders. “But
nothing,” says Dupin, “shows the imposture of these two
letters more palpably than the difference of style from those truly
ascribed to Cornelius in Cyprian’s works.”
42.
A Third Letter,
etc
.—Equally false on its face. Dupin, with his usual
candour, remarks: “We find in it the word
‘Mass,’ which was unknown to the contemporaries of
Cornelius.”
43.
An Epistle of Lucius
.—It is
dated six months before he became Bishop of Rome, and quotes authors
who lived ages after he was dead.
44.
An Epistle of
Stephen
.—“Filled with citations out of subsequent
authors.”
45.
A Second Epistle, etc
.—Open
to the like objection; it does not harmonize with the times to which it
is referred.
Here Dupin grows weary, and winds up his review as
follows:—
For like reasons, we must pass judgment, in like manner,
on the two Epistles of Sixtus II.; the two of Dionysius; the three of
St. Felix I; the two of Eutychianus; one of Caius; two of Marcellinus
and those
of Marcellus; the
three of Eusebius; those of Miltiades, and the rest of Isidore’s
collection: they are full of passages out of Fathers, Popes, and
councils, more modern than the very Popes by whom they are pretended to
be written. In them are many things that clash with the known
history of those times, and were
purposely framed to favour the
court of Rome and to sustain her pretensions against the rights of
bishops and the liberties of churches
. But it would take up
too much time to show the gross falsehood of these monuments.
They are now rejected by common consent, and even by those authors who
are most favourable to the court of Rome, who are obliged to abandon
the patronage of these epistles, though they have done a great deal of
service in developing the greatness of the court of Rome, and
ruining the ancient discipline of the Church
, especially with
reference to the rights of bishops and ecclesiastical
decisions.
The following is the
Translator’s Preface
to these
frauds:—
In
regard to these
Decretals, Dean Milman says: “Up to this period the
Decretals, the letters or edicts of the Bishops of Rome, according to
the authorized or common collection of Dionysius, commenced with Pope
Siricius, towards the close of the fourth century. To the
collection of Dionysius was added that of the authentic councils, which
bore the name of Isidore of Seville. On a sudden was promulgated,
unannounced, without preparation, not absolutely unquestioned, but
apparently overawing at once all doubt, a new code, which to the former
authentic documents added fifty-nine letters and decrees of the twenty
oldest popes from Clement to Melchiades,
2691
and the donation of Constantine;
2692
and in the
third part, among the decrees of the popes and of the councils from
Sylvester to Gregory II., thirty-nine false decrees, and the acts of
several unauthentic councils.”
2693
In regard to the authorship and date of the False
Decretals, Dean Milman says: “The author or authors of this
most audacious and elaborate of pious frauds are unknown; the date and
place of its compilation are driven into such narrow limits that they
may be determined within a few years, and within a very circumscribed
region. The False Decretals came not from Rome; the time of their
arrival at Rome, after they were known beyond the Alps, appears almost
certain. In one year Nicholas I. is apparently ignorant of their
existence; the next he speaks of them with full knowledge. They
contain words manifestly used at the Council of Paris,
a.d.
829, consequently are of later date. They were
known to the Levite Benedict of Mentz, who composed a supplement to the
collection of capitularies by Ansegise, between
a.d.
840–847. The city of Mentz is designated
with nearly equal certainty as the place in which, if not actually
composed, they were first promulgated as the canon law of
Christendom.”
2694
2681
Compare these
Canons: Nicæa, vi.; Constantinople, ii., iii.; Ephesus,
viii.; and Chalcedon, xxviii.
2682
Episcopus ab
extra
; i.e., head of temporalities.
2683
Hincmar
of Rheims opposed them as he could. See Prichard’s
Hincmar
, Oxford, 1849.
2684
See vol. v. p.
154, Elucidation III.
2685
See his
Eccles. History
, Cent. iii. p. 173, ed. London, 1693.
2686
Ed. Hayes,
London, 1868.
2687
De Ord.
Sacram
., § 49.
2688
§ 5.
2689
P. 173, as
above.
2690
Elucidation
II.,
infra
.
2691
[Elucidation
I.]
2692
[Elucidation
II.]
2693
History of
Latin Christianity
, vol. iii. p. 191.
2694
History of
Latin Christianity
, vol. iii. p. 193. [In the marvellous
confusion of vol. ix. of the Edinburgh series, these Decretals are
mixed up with genuine works as “Fragments of the Third
Century.”]