14. But this is not so with things originate and
creatures; for when the Father works, it is not that any Angel works,
or any other creature; for none of these is an efficient cause Or. ii. 21, n. 2., but they are of things which come to be;
and moreover being separate and divided from the only God, and other in
nature, and being works, they can neither work what God works, nor, as
I said before, when God gives grace, can they give grace with Him. Nor,
on seeing an Angel would a man say that he had seen the Father; for
Angels, as it is written, are ‘ministering spirits sent forth to
minister Heb. i. 14.,’ and are heralds of gifts given
by Him through the Word to those who receive them. And the Angel on his
appearance, himself confesses that he has been sent by his Lord; as
Gabriel confessed in the case of Zacharias, and also in the case of
Mary, bearer of God τῆς
θεοτόκου
Μαρίας.
[Prolegg. ch. iv. §5.] vid. also infr. 29, 33. Orat.
iv. 32. Incarn. c. Ar. 8, 22. supr. Or. i. 45, n. 3. As
to the history of this title, Theodoret, who from his party would
rather be disinclined towards it, says that the most ancient
(τῶν
πάλαι καὶ
πρόπαλαι) heralds of the orthodox faith taught to name and believe the
Mother of the Lord θεοτόκον, according to ‘the Apostolical tradition.’
Hær. iv. 12. And John of Antioch, whose championship of
Nestorius and quarrel with S. Cyril are well known, writes to the
former. ‘This title no ecclesiastical teacher has put aside;
those who have used it are many and eminent, and those who have not
used it have not attacked those who used it.’ Concil. Eph.
part i. c. 25 (Labb.). Socrates Hist. vii. 32. says that Origen,
in the first tome of his Comment on the Romans (vid. de la Rue in Rom.
lib. i. 5. the original is lost), treated largely of the word; which
implies that it was already in use. ‘Interpreting,’ he
says, ‘how θεοτόκος is used, he discussed the question at length.’
Constantine implies the same in a passage which divines, e.g. Pearson
(On the Creed, notes on Art. 3.), have not dwelt upon (or rather
have apparently overlooked, in arguing from Ephrem. ap. Phot.
Cod. 228, p. 776. that the literal phrase ‘Mother of
God’ originated in S. Leo). [See vol. 1, p. 569 of this
Series.]. And he who beholds
a vision of Angels, knows that he has seen the Angel and not God. For
Zacharias saw an Angel; and Isaiah saw the Lord. Manoah, the father of
Samson, saw an Angel; but Moses beheld God. Gideon saw an Angel, but to
Abraham appeared God. And neither he who saw God, beheld an Angel, nor
he who saw an Angel, considered that he saw God; for greatly, or rather
wholly, do things by nature originate differ from God the Creator. But
if at any time, when the Angel was seen, he who saw it heard
God’s voice, as took place at the bush; for ‘the Angel of
the Lord was seen in a flame of fire out of the bush, and the Lord
called Moses out of the bush, saying, I am the God of thy father, the
God of Abraham and the God of Isaac and the God of Jacob Vid. Ex. iii. 2–6.,’ yet was not the Angel the God of Abraham, but in the Angel
God spoke. And what was seen was an Angel; but God spoke in him §12, note 2.. For as He spoke to Moses in the pillar of a
cloud in the tabernacle, so also God appears and speaks in Angels. So
again to the son of Nun He spake by an Angel. But what God speaks, it
is very plain He speaks through the Word, and not through another. And
the Word, as being not separate from the Father, nor unlike and foreign
to the Father’s Essence, what He works, those are the
Father’s works, and His framing of all things is one with His;
and what the Son gives, that is the Father’s gift. And he who
hath seen the Son, knows that, in seeing Him, he has seen, not Angel,
nor one merely greater than Angels, nor in short any creature, but the
Father Himself. And he who hears the Word, knows that he hears the
Father; as he who is irradiated by the radiance, knows that he is
enlightened by the sun.