Chapter II.—An Analysis of Augustin’s Writings Against the Donatists.
The object of this chapter is to present a rudimentary outline and summary of all that
Augustin penned or spoke against those traditional North African Christians whom he was
pleased to regard as schismatics. It will be arranged, so far as may be, in chronological order,
following the dates suggested by the Benedictine edition. The necessary brevity precludes
anything but a very meagre treatment of so considerable a theme. The writer takes no re-
sponsibility for the ecclesiological tenets of the great Father, nor will he enter here into any
criticism of the text and truth of the documents, upon which the historical argument was
so laboriously and peremptorily built, to the utter ignoring of the Donatist archives, and
the protests of their scholars against the validity and integrity of their opponents’ records.
Both parties claimed to be the historic Catholic church; both were little apart in doctrine,
worship, and polity; both tended toward externalism in piety; both accused one another of
fraud in inventing records. Later Romanism in its bright spirit of selection took much spoil
from either camp.
373
The city of Augustin’s birth, its neighborhood, indeed the whole ecclesiastical province
of Numidia, was a stronghold for this puristic school. Is it not singular, then, that it seems
to have made no impression upon his early years? As a child he had witnessed its brief
restoration under Julian, and then the severe or lax efforts at suppression under succeeding
emperors; the Rogatian schism and the Tychonian reformation were quite familiar to him
in his Manichæan period; but the Confessions are silent as to any such stamp or hold upon
his mind. His activity begins with his ordination to the presbyterate, a time marked in
Donatist annals by the Maximianist separation, and increases as he becomes bishop. From
about 392 to near the close of his life, pen and voice were seldom still. In all those years the
outlinear thoughts grew in breadth and depth; endless are the forms in which his few and
radical conceptions manifest themselves; never does he lose sight of the popular effect, so
that he knows when to relax his love of word-play and delight in mysterious inductions, in
order to make the chief themes plain to the dullest mind.
How varied the channels through which he struggled for the mastery of his idea of the
Church! In the pulpit he made Donatism the occasion of many a polemic, many an appeal;
in his correspondence it was an ever-recurrent topic; it was the staple of many a tract and
book; verse was not shunned to destroy its fashionableness and popularity; commentaries
and manuals for the meditative hour or for the training of the theological student, abounded
in warnings against its aggressiveness; no opportunity for debate or conference or epistolary
discussion was left unimproved. And no wonder: it was a living thing, of the street, of the
market, of the social circle, of the home; it threatened at times to obliterate the transmarine
view of the church from North Africa; its spirit of political independence and plea for reli-
gious liberty went to the hearts of a people, more and more restive under the decline of the
Empire.
An Analysis of Augustin’s Writings Against the Donatists.
648
An Analysis of Augustin’s Writings Against the Donatists.