Polycarp’s martyrdom occurred in Smyrna, not during the
reign of Marcus Aurelius, as Eusebius says, but during the reign of
Antoninus Pius, between 154 and 156 (probably in 155). This has been
proved by Waddington in his Memoire sur la Chronologie de la vie du
rheteur Ælius Aristide (in Mem. de l’acad. des
inscript. et belles lettres, Tom. XXVI., part II., 1867, p. 232
sq.’ see, also, his Fastes des provinces Asiatiques, 1872,
p. 219 sq.), and the date is now almost universally accepted (for
example, by Renan, Ewald, Hilgenfeld, Lightfoot, Harnack, &c.). But
the Chron. of Eusebius seems to put the martyrdom in the seventh
year of Marcus Aurelius (166–167 a.d.),
and this is the date given by Jerome and others, who based their
chronology upon Eusebius, and was commonly accepted until Waddington
proved it false. Lightfoot, however, shows that Eusebius did not mean
to assign Polycarp’s death to the seventh year of Marcus
Aurelius, but that he meant only to place it in the reign of that
emperor, and did not pretend to fix the year. How he made the mistake
of assigning it to the wrong emperor we do not know, but knowing
Eusebius’ common confusion of the various emperors that bore the
name of Antonine, we are not surprised at his error at this point. For
the best and most recent discussion of this whole subject, see
Lightfoot’s Ignatius, I. p. 629 sq. Since Waddington
published his researches, Wieseler (in his Christenverfolgungen,
1878, p. 34–87) and Keim (Aus dem Urchristenthum, 1878, p.
92–133) have ventured to dispute his conclusions and to advocate
the old date (167), but their arguments are worthless, and have been
completely refuted by Lightfoot (ibid. p. 655 sq.).