they defile the man. For out of the heart proceed evil thoughts, murders, adulteries, fornic-
ations, thefts, false witness, blasphemies. These are the things which defile a man: but to
eat with unwashen hands defileth not a man."632
32. Here we have a complete exposure of the falsehood of the Manichæans: for it is
plain that the Lord did not in this matter teach one thing to the multitude, and another in
private to His disciples. Here is abundant evidence that the error and deceit are in the
Manichæans, and not in Moses, nor in Christ, nor in the doctrine taught figuratively in one
Testament and plainly in the other,—prophesied in one, and fulfilled in the other. How
can the Manichæans say that the Catholics regard none of the things that Moses wrote,
when in fact they observe them all, not now in the figures, but in what the figures were in-
tended to foretell? No one would say that one who reads the Scripture subsequently to its
being written does not observe it because he does not form the letters which he reads. The
letters are the figures of the sounds which he utters; and though he does not form the letters,
he cannot read without examining them. The reason why the Jews did not believe in Christ,
was because they did not observe even the plain literal precepts of Moses. So Christ says to
them: "Ye pay tithe of mint and cummin, and omit the weightier matters of the law, mercy
and judgment. Ye strain out a gnat and swallow a camel. These ought ye to have done, and
not to leave the other undone."633 So also He told them that by their traditions they made
of none effect the commandment of God to give honor to parents. On account of this pride
and perversity in neglecting what they understood, they were justly blinded, so that they
could not understand the other things.
234
33. You see, my argument is not that if you are a Christian you must believe Christ
when He says that Moses wrote of Him, and that if you do not believe this you are no
Christian. The account you give of yourself in asking to be dealt with as a Jew or a Gentile
is your own affair. My endeavor is to leave no avenue of error open to you. I have shut you
out, too, from that precipice to which you rush as a last resort, when you say that these are
spurious passages in the Gospel; so that, freed from the pernicious influence of this opinion,
you may be reduced to the necessity of believing in Christ. You say you wish to be taught
like the Christian Thomas, whom Christ did not spurn from Him because he doubted of
Him, but, in order to heal the wounds of his mind, showed him the marks of the wounds
in His own body. These are your own words. It is well that you desire to be taught as
Thomas was. I feared you would make out this passage too to be spurious. Believe, then,
the marks of Christ’s wounds. For if the marks were real, the wounds must have been real.
And the wounds could not have been real, unless His body had been capable of real wounds;
which upsets at once the whole error of the Manichæans. If you say that the marks were
632 Matt. xv. 16-20.
633 Matt. xxiii. 23, 24.
398
Faustus willing to believe not only that the Jewish but that all Gentile…