284i INSTITUTES OF THE [bOOK II
life, but also that those wills which relate to the present life,
are subject tc the power of God, so that he, by a most secret,
but yet a most righteous judgment, causes them to be inclined
whither he pleases, and when he pleases, either for the com-
munication of benefits, or for the infliction of punishments.''
VIII. Here let the reader remember, that the ability of the
human will is not to be estimated from the event of things, as
some ignorant men are preposterously accustomed to do. For
they conceive themselves fully and ingeniously to establish the
servitude of the human will, because even the most exalted
monarchs have not all their desires fulfilled. But this ability,
of which we speak, is to be considered within man, and not to
be measured by external success. For in the dispute concern-
ing free will, the question is not, whether a man, notwithstand-
ing external impediments, can perform and execute whatever
he may have resolved in his mind, but whether in every case
his judgment exerts freedom of choice, and his will freedom
of inclination. If men possess both these, then Attilius Re-
gulus,when confined to the small extent of a cask stuck round
with nails, will possess as much free will as Augustus Caesar,
when governing a great part of the world with his nod.
K
..r
•'h
CHAPTER V.
e^
A REFUTATION OF THE OBJECTIONS COMMONLY URGED IN SUPPORT
OF FREE WILL.
Enough might appear to have been already said on the ser-
vitude of the human will, did not they, who endeavour to over-
throw it with a false notion of liberty, allege, on the contrary,
certain reasons in opposition to our sentiments. First, they
collect together some absurdities, in order to render it odious,
as if it were abhorrent to common sense ; and then they attack
it with testimonies of Scripture. Both these weapons we will
repel in order. If sin,jay they, be necessary, then it ceases to
be sin; if it be voTuntary, "then it may be~avoided._ These
were also the weapons used by Pelaguis in his attacks on Au-
gustine ; with whose authority, however, we wish not to urge
them, till we shall have given some satisfaction on the subject
Itself, t deny, then, that sin is the less crmiinal, because it is
necessary ; I deny also the other consequence, which they
infer, that it is avoidable because it is voluntary. For, if
any one wish to dispute with God, and to escape his judgment