κατὰ τὸν
παρόντα
λόγον. Eusebius seems
to refer here to the eighth book of his History; for he
uses λόγος frequently
in referring to the separate books of his work, but nowhere else, so
far as I am aware, in referring to the work as a whole. This would seem
to indicate that he was thinking at this time of writing only eight
books, and of bringing his History to an end with the toleration
edict of Galerius, which he gives in chap. 17, below. Might it be
supposed that the present passage was written immediately after the
publication of the edict of Galerius, and before the renewal of the
persecution by Maximin? If that were so, we might assume that after the
close of that persecution, in consequence of the victory of Constantine
and Licinius, the historian felt it necessary to add yet a ninth book
to his work, not contemplated at the time he was writing his eighth; as
he seems still later, after the victory of Constantine over Licinius,
to have found it necessary to add a tenth book, in order that his work
might cover the entire period of persecution and include the final
triumph of the Church. His motive, indeed, in adding the tenth book
seems not to have been to bring the history down to the latest date
possible, for he made no additions during his later years, in spite of
the interesting and exciting events which took place after 325 a.d., but to bring it down to the final triumph of
the Church over her pagan enemies. Had there been another persecution
and another toleration edict between 325 and 338, we can hardly doubt
that Eusebius would have added an account of it to his History.
In view of these considerations, it is possible that some time may have
elapsed between the composition of the eighth and ninth books, as well
as between the composition of the ninth and tenth.
It must be admitted,
however, that a serious objection to this supposition lies in the fact
that in chaps. 15 and 16, below, the tenth year of the persecution is
spoken of, and in the latter chapter the author is undoubtedly thinking
of the Edict of Milan, which was issued in 312, after the renewal of
Maximin’s persecution described in Book IX. I am, nevertheless,
inclined to think that Eusebius, when he wrote the present passage, was
expecting to close his work with the present book, and that the
necessity for another book made itself manifest before he finished the
present one. It may be that the words in chaps. 15 and 16 are a later
insertion. I do not regard this as probable, but knowing the changes
that were made in the ninth book in a second edition of the
History, it must be admitted that such changes in the eighth
book are not impossible (see above, p. 30 and 45). At the same time I
prefer the former alternative, that the necessity for another book
became manifest before he finished the present one. A slight
confirmation of the theory that the ninth book was a later addition,
necessitated by the persecution of Maximin’s later years, may be
found in the appendix to the eighth book which is found in many mss. See below, p. 340, note 1.