Johnson says: “This contains
the Canon of Scripture as we now receive it in all respects, save that
the Epistle of Baruch is reckoned in the Canon, but Esther is
not. He tells us, there are other books never reckoned in the
Canon but authorized by the fathers to be read by the Catechumens,
viz.: Wisdom of Solomon, of Sirach, Esther, Judith, and Tobias,
and that which is called The Doctrine of the Apostles, and
Pastor. These (says he) are read, the other reckoned of
the Canons: Apocryphal books are the invention of
heretics.” To this Johnson appends a note, to wit:
“It is the common opinion of learned men that the reason why some
of the ancients reckoned the book of Esther not to belong to the Canon,
was the Apocryphal chapters added to it by another hand. That
The Doctrine of the Apostles is a book now lost, see Dr.
Grabe’s Essay on this subject.”
Who these “learned men” may
be, I do not know, but at the time of the writing of St. Athanasius the
position of the Hebrew Esther was not well assured in the restricted
Palestinian Jewish Canon. On this point the reader should make
himself familiar with The Canon of the Old Testament by the Rt.
Rev. Tobias Mullen, Roman Catholic Bishop of Erie, U.S.A.